I will take your lack of response as capitulation to the toxic and completely ridiculous claims you were making. Now we can move on!

If you have a single example of a game where you think the game was flawed and you got unfairly treated by all means cite it. I can call up multiple examples of games where you deliberately used your position to hurt me or screw me over specifically and it wasnt even the rand. Your unfair administra...

First off dont come flying in here calling my games bastard and my methodology bastard. Show me real examples of bastard games ive run. No backpedalling. No whataboutisms. Prove your talking point that used as toxic of verbiage as possible.

The far more problematic issues with games recently has not been gm rand decisions. Its been poorly balanced or totally imbalanved setups. Random new rules being pushed or rescinded at random. Player numbers dwindling and a council that lacked membership. Too many role madness setups from gms which ...

If you can think of any game of mine you played in where you feel the result was bastard we can go to the scoresheet and mark them as no contest. I have already stated I will randomize the upcoming game with zero gm influence on the semi open roles and on the actual rand. Just a one off roll and let...

I invite anyone in any game of mine to cite an instance where they feel my system created a bastard game.

Please provide exact examples of what you are accusing me of and what you feel in each case created a fraudulent outcome

Are we going to create a culture then of players not willing to sign up unless the GM publishes their exact methods of how they distribute their setup? I feel like were just creating doubt and retconning a decade of games from this forum, casting doubt on the results of years of games, and throwing ...

I think there is just so much misunderstanding happening here. As well as assumptions. Ive never adopted a hard line stance that if some player has been vt too many times in a row I would deliberately alter that to force them to be mafia. I dont pick individual battles within a rand to decide someth...

I only think that the game would be better with more oversight now that I know the general sentiments on randomization that you stated and quoted. How do you feel knowing this has always been how it is, and you were just blissfully unaware? I don't think it's super common, but it's a tool in the GM...

the result is still random, im just allowed to see a spread of possibilites and choose one. I dont find that to be a flawed way to do things. Truly, the fact that you think this is not flawed (i.e., randing three times and picking your favorite) is a big concern. I believe that the whole point of t...

A Mafia game is a production event. There is a cast of characters, a plot, an engine and all things therein run through its director whose first duty is to provide a fun, fair, and high quality game. I dont think we need more micromanagement into the GMs on this forum. but we have a kouncil who can ...

the result is still random, im just allowed to see a spread of possibilites and choose one. I dont find that to be a flawed way to do things.

I can tell you from past experiences that I have been in games where I suspected I was not randomly assigned what I ended up with. But I also didnt care, and its quite the accusation to just claim the GM rigged the game right? I dont have any actual proof it happened. From the other side of the hat,...

Proposal 11: All setups must be randomized by a kouncil member to avoid GM involvement in the setups distribution and rng. That kouncil member must not be a player or co gm, or gm in the game, and will not be a sub either. (if you feel inclined to enforce this standard here is a proposal) Officially...

As was stated in discord, I think the following opinions reflect responsible GMing standards that are intended to provide the least amount of handpicking or tampering. I support where a GM gets either 1-2 adjustments, or up to 3 rng rolls -brainbomb I will admit i have fully rerolled setups in very ...

Who is hungry for more?

dilly dilly!

While I agree in principle that LOTR is limited, evidentally there are wings of barely canon and not even canon material at all that are starting to come into play. Rings of power, War of the Rohirram, Search for Smeagol. Not that im a huge fan of the non canon or barely canon; but I see more potent...

Hes talking about creating a free university where people can finish degrees they may have started years ago and they would get to have their credits recognized. This is a very incredible idea, and then he ruins it by adding that this will be the new recognized form of accreditation for all governme...

This sounds like some nazi Germany shit on the rest of this page. But this line made me chuckle.

"It will be strictly non-political, and there will be no wokeness or jihadism allowed—none of that's going to be allowed. "