Mafia 88: Murder at the Meadery - GAME THREAD

[sweetandcool]

Bozo, if you are claiming to have a Guilty scan on Hamilton Brian, just come out and say it, and town can win the game.

I just voted END in case there was a consensus to end the day early. We probably should not hammer until kingofthepirates comes back.

I feel the same way. Going to be busy, I'll leave a hammer in case it expedites things.

##END

[sweetandcool]

Oh yeah, best case for Town Ham:

1. Mafia prioritized NK/RB for Ham defenders, implying they believed they were Clerk, implying they Town scanned Ham, implying Ham is Town.

2. Mafia targeted someone who hyposcanned Ham as Town, implying that is a correct scan.

3. Mafia seemed to prioritize Ham's survival (actually, NAI since Ham being Mafia would equally explain it) to preserve an easy MK.

Honestly, I think the best case would be to find a better candidate, so I suppose building a case on Pirate would be the best avenue.

[bozotheclown]

Bozo, if you are claiming to have a Guilty scan on Hamilton Brian, just come out and say it, and town can win the game.

I just voted END in case there was a consensus to end the day early. We probably should not hammer until kingofthepirates comes back.

I feel the same way. Going to be busy, I'll leave a hammer in case it expedites things.

##END

The bot did not count your vote for kingofthepirates, but it was probably a valid vote.

[bozotheclown]

##UNEND

It does not look like the day is going to end early, so lets see if kingofthepirates shows up.

kingofthepirates getting mod-killed would be beneficial to town, since we could resolve Hamilton and kingofthepirates.

[sweetandcool]

##UNEND

It does not look like the day is going to end early, so lets see if kingofthepirates shows up.

kingofthepirates getting mod-killed would be beneficial to town, since we could resolve Hamilton and kingofthepirates.

If Pirate got modkilled, that would be in addition to the DK?

Yeah, that would be a dream. Pretty sure that ends the game, but if not we would be fortunate to have one last chance to win the game.

[Hamilton Brian]

Bozo, if you are claiming to have a Guilty scan on Hamilton Brian, just come out and say it, and town can win the game.

I just voted END in case there was a consensus to end the day early. We probably should not hammer until kingofthepirates comes back.

What information do you have that makes you certain that a blanket END vote is prudent?

[Jamiet99uk]

##UNEND
kingofthepirates getting mod-killed would be beneficial to town, since we could resolve Hamilton and kingofthepirates.

What if he is the cop?

I happen to think two town dying would be beneficial to the one remaining scum, Bozo, as it happens.

[Jamiet99uk]

If Pirate got modkilled, that would be in addition to the DK?

Yes.

[Jamiet99uk]

Remaining players, ranked from Town to Scum:

Jamiet99uk
sweetandcool
Bonatogether
kingofthepirates
Hamilton Brian
bozotheclown

[sweetandcool]

Remaining players, ranked from Town to Scum:

Jamiet99uk
sweetandcool
Bonatogether
kingofthepirates
Hamilton Brian
bozotheclown

I'm flattered.

Could you please provide a case for prioritizing Bozo over Ham or Pirate?

I know you haven't liked his play today, and possibly more or less the entire game.

But you don't think any of the evidence I have provided is compelling enough?

[Jamiet99uk]

Remaining players, ranked from Town to Scum:

Jamiet99uk
sweetandcool
Bonatogether
kingofthepirates
Hamilton Brian
bozotheclown

I'm flattered.

Could you please provide a case for prioritizing Bozo over Ham or Pirate?

I know you haven't liked his play today, and possibly more or less the entire game.

But you don't think any of the evidence I have provided is compelling enough?

He is playing the way scum might play if they were down to one person and desperate to cause some miskills to give them a chance to get to the final three.

[sweetandcool]

Remaining players, ranked from Town to Scum:

Jamiet99uk
sweetandcool
Bonatogether
kingofthepirates
Hamilton Brian
bozotheclown

I'm flattered.

Could you please provide a case for prioritizing Bozo over Ham or Pirate?

I know you haven't liked his play today, and possibly more or less the entire game.

But you don't think any of the evidence I have provided is compelling enough?

He is playing the way scum might play if they were down to one person and desperate to cause some miskills to give them a chance to get to the final three.

Perhaps. Does he fit in with the scum team the best, taking into account D1-D6? That's also important.

[kingofthepirates]

Hey y'all, sorry for my long leave of absence. I've been going through a stressful week of AP and other exams, I've totally forgotten and neglected this game. Super sorry to everyone, and thanks to Chaqa for reminding me. If anyone is willing, a summary would be nice. Otherwise, I'll make my way through the time I have missed and throw out whatever thoughts I have.

[sweetandcool]

Hey y'all, sorry for my long leave of absence. I've been going through a stressful week of AP and other exams, I've totally forgotten and neglected this game. Super sorry to everyone, and thanks to Chaqa for reminding me. If anyone is willing, a summary would be nice. Otherwise, I'll make my way through the time I have missed and throw out whatever thoughts I have.

5 Town, 1 Scum left.

Balki was the NK and flipped Miller, sweetandcool was the RB.

Currently, nobody is claiming Clerk, which implies the game is not solved.

There has been tons of analysis, probably relevant starting since last Day phase.

Personally, I've concluded Ham is likely the final Mafia, with you being a possible yet unlikely alternative.

My impression is that Bozo agrees with my assessment, and so does Jamiet though he ranks Bozo as most likely Mafia.

Unknown what Bona thinks.

Ham of course disagrees, but really hasn't settled on a final scum choice.

Your assignment, I suppose, is to lay out a case for why you are not the final Mafia, and/or why Ham or Bozo is the final Mafia.

Bona and I should be off the table. Maybe you could make a case for Jamiet if you really felt convicted.

[sweetandcool]

Technically a biased summary, but I promise you a helpful one.

[kingofthepirates]

I'll be real, from what I've seen, it honestly seems like a big 'ol nothing burger. we're still roughly the same place we were at yesterday, albeit with 1 less mafia. ham and I are both on the chopping block, and it seems that Jamie (perhaps someone else too? I don't think so, but I may be wrong) would like to flip bozo.

I don't see anything that particularly sticks out so far. Balki's death is super sad and unfortunate, I really loved his vibe. He pulled off a great cop facade too. I'm going for a run, will share more thoughts and answer questions when I return.

[Jamiet99uk]

I'll be real, from what I've seen, it honestly seems like a big 'ol nothing burger. we're still roughly the same place we were at yesterday, albeit with 1 less mafia. ham and I are both on the chopping block, and it seems that Jamie (perhaps someone else too? I don't think so, but I may be wrong) would like to flip bozo.

I don't see anything that particularly sticks out so far. Balki's death is super sad and unfortunate, I really loved his vibe. He pulled off a great cop facade too. I'm going for a run, will share more thoughts and answer questions when I return.

This is all you have to say?

Wow, ok.

[Jamiet99uk]

I assume the Cop:

- Does not have a guilty scan on a living player.
and
- Does not have an inno scan on Hamilton.

[sweetandcool]

I assume the Cop:

- Does not have a guilty scan on a living player.
and
- Does not have an inno scan on Hamilton.

I pretty much assume that too. Otherwise we would either get a claim or some strong argument against it or for another player.

[sweetandcool]

For a moment I forgot about Balki being Clerk. That would also explain it, even if the Clerk had a guilty.