MAfIA 84 - A VERY TENDER THANKSGIVING GAME THREAD

[ghug]

Hi Macca, you're alive.

[TheMadMonarch]

Hi Macca, you're alive.

Yeah, ig

[TheMadMonarch]

##VOTE bofa

Who's bofa?

[damo666]

So I went from towncore to scummy in your mind by suggesting there was bussing, something the majority of the game agrees with?

You were never towncore and not particularly scummy but I have a nagging feeling that your bus comment may have been a clever scum deception. I put you at something like 65% town. Need to over 80% to be towncore.

So then why were worc and spirit towncore and not me before that comment?

Odds of the average living player being town are 79% so your math is also pretty sus.

Tone.

I just picked 80% as a round number > 11/14. 90 would've been better. Anyway as you keep pursuing this I think the likelihood you were bussing diminishes.

I am now thinking all 3 mafia were off sweet and I think we should concentrate on this group. The strategy is still sound with one busser.

In fact I would be inclined to vote anyone off sweet who votes for a sweet voter.

[damo666]

But actually ##VOTE bona though

I assume this is a jocular reaction vote and not one that will last.
Bona ain't scum.

[Jamiet99uk]

- Idk how to embed posts yet but the top response in this post just feels like weird word choice to me: https://webdiplomacy.net/contrib/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?p=365965#p365965

Use the big square button with quotation marks in it.

[Jamiet99uk]

##VOTE bofa

Who's bofa?

Oh no.

[Hamilton Brian]

I think I want to take an opposite approach than damo.

I look at Sweet's vote as bookends with Spirit (confirmed town) right in the middle.

I feel like there was one busser on there before Spirit. Then with 31 minutes to go, Spirit ties it, then bozo nails it.

In group A there's mafia amongst worcej, ghug, and bona. In group B there's mafia amongst jamie, just, and damo.

Group A is the one that's wrankling me more because after reading D1, I like those 3 (like, as in consider them more town than not). Group B, I'm looking at jamie and just as who I like least. However, does damo bus with a minute left for some credibility gain?

[Jamiet99uk]

Hamilton Brian:

You keep shading me.

I keep asking you to clarify your suspicions of me in more detail.

You keep ignoring that request.

What giveth?

[Hamilton Brian]

I also have a strong suspicion that sweet did bus on D1 so it wouldn't be out of the question to flip Just today.

[rdrivera2005]

You were never towncore and not particularly scummy but I have a nagging feeling that your bus comment may have been a clever scum deception. I put you at something like 65% town. Need to over 80% to be towncore.

So then why were worc and spirit towncore and not me before that comment?

Odds of the average living player being town are 79% so your math is also pretty sus.

Tone.

I just picked 80% as a round number > 11/14. 90 would've been better. Anyway as you keep pursuing this I think the likelihood you were bussing diminishes.

I am now thinking all 3 mafia were off sweet and I think we should concentrate on this group. The strategy is still sound with one busser.

In fact I would be inclined to vote anyone off sweet who votes for a sweet voter.

I don't agree much with this approach as this is mostly mechanical and not considering people's reasoning. It makes also easier for scum to hide if you voted Sweet you are safe. If you didn't vote Sweet just vote other non Sweet voter and you are safe. Lazy approach.

[Hamilton Brian]

Hamilton Brian:

You keep shading me.

I keep asking you to clarify your suspicions of me in more detail.

You keep ignoring that request.

What giveth?

I shade you because you're shady. There's been a couple of things you've said on D1 that raise my hockles. Maybe as mafia you're not careless like that, but then maybe you're trying something new out.

[Temasek22]

why is temasek a leading wagon at this moment

Long story short I've been lurking too much and my voting record sticks out like a sore thumb (only person to vote sweet at one point before moving off). If I were anyone else I'd probs find myself somewhat suspicious as well.

[Temasek22]

I think I want to take an opposite approach than damo.

I look at Sweet's vote as bookends with Spirit (confirmed town) right in the middle.

I feel like there was one busser on there before Spirit. Then with 31 minutes to go, Spirit ties it, then bozo nails it.

In group A there's mafia amongst worcej, ghug, and bona. In group B there's mafia amongst jamie, just, and damo.

Group A is the one that's wrankling me more because after reading D1, I like those 3 (like, as in consider them more town than not). Group B, I'm looking at jamie and just as who I like least. However, does damo bus with a minute left for some credibility gain?

Just's vote is hard to analyse because he could be newbie town just throwing a vote to the other wagon in an attempt to save himself (alternatively, scum throwing a desperation vote against his teammate to save himself)

I do, however, agree with you on Group A, especially worcej and Bona who I feel are both almost certainly town.

[Temasek22]

##Vote Macca

Gone through her iso and she has posted zero concrete reads and half of her posts are about her out of game relation with Bona. I'm usually a lurker but this is just taking lurking to brand new dimensions

[Jamiet99uk]

Hamilton Brian:

You keep shading me.

I keep asking you to clarify your suspicions of me in more detail.

You keep ignoring that request.

What giveth?

I shade you because you're shady. There's been a couple of things you've said on D1 that raise my hockles. Maybe as mafia you're not careless like that, but then maybe you're trying something new out.

Which things?

Give specifics.

[Jamiet99uk]

Hamilton Brian's shading of me is quite scummy.

Look at how he repeatedly makes these extremely vague comments about how he thinks I'm scummy, but does not quote specific posts.

He makes reference to "a peculiar moment" from me, without specifying what moment that was.

He mentions a "Jamie as mafia" theory without expounding on his theory, and even if he has suggested he no longer strongly believes that theory, it bothers me that he never set out any theory in the first place.

More recently he says I am one of the two people he "likes the least". But again, no actual reason for this.

[Jamiet99uk]

This is not OMGUS, before anyone suggests it is.

Hamilton's repeated shading of me is scummy for the reasons I have just set out.

[Hamilton Brian]

I've got two particular moments. If it's picked up by others then I'll feel validated. If not, then I'll know that I was probably on the wrong track.

If you were OMGUS-ing as mafia, I'd expect you to do it more subtly.

Or would you...?

[Bonatogether]

why is temasek a leading wagon at this moment

Long story short I've been lurking too much and my voting record sticks out like a sore thumb (only person to vote sweet at one point before moving off). If I were anyone else I'd probs find myself somewhat suspicious as well.

people should just vote for who i want