MAFIA 79: The Price is Right! [GAME THREAD]

[sweetandcool]

In case anybody cares, my ranking list is:

Townie:
Bonatogether

Neutral-Positive:
Jamiet
Dousing
bozo

Neutral/Null:
chaqa
damo

Neutral-Negative:
rdrive
President Eden

Mafia:
Koala
Snowy

Now I'll do a proper investigation on Koala, though it will probably be in a few hours. Who knows, maybe my opinion on them will change.

[sweetandcool]

I have a better one now. I must be Mafia because I have been mis-spelling Balrog all this freaking time. Thanks Jamiet for pointing that out.

##VOTE KoalaAttack

for justice in the world. (Don't worry SnowyBalrog, I'll probably come back to you before EOD after someone else who suspects you but doesn't wanna wagon-share with me does.)

All along I thought that your mentions of Barlog was slang referring to an incredibly stiff poo.

[KoalaAttack]

OK my case on Snowy is growing as Snowy is posting but ignoring my repeating questioning...

Because as far as I can tell they have no actual rationale for their hardlock of me as Mafia to share...



This is the best I can find:

i think i'm pretty clearly cooler as i wasn't born in the previous millennium like a boomer

When we flip you as Mafia, if I'm still alive, I'll say "boom" just for you.

Speaking of reasons why I actually believe something, I direct people to review this comment

In other words, they hardlock me as Mafia for using a definitive "when" instead of "if" inside a joke banter post with Bona.

Cool, cool..

But of course, how is is that any different from any of these (just a few I found after a cursory 2 min search):

Let's play a fun game many of you will enjoy:
- everyone post their case on Koala
- everyone vote Koala
- everyone post in advance of EOD what will be your learning when (if form your perspective) Koala flips Town
- flip me Town

My VCA, Bona's essay, your wierdness
Already voting you
You won't
We won't
[/quote]

koala i have a question for you

why are you scum

i'm going to read the OP

earliest setup reading mafia player

The best part is – the last one is by Snowy themselves!

So Snowy – you are a Mafia hardlock because you didn't say "if" when you said Bona is the earliest setup reading mafia player – riiiiight? You just stated it as a fact. Clearly, you can only know this from Mafia chat.



Like, people say different versions of essentially "you are Mafia" or "when you flip Mafia I'll be vindicated" all the time. Including Snowy themselves!

But somehow Snowy picks out the one instance I do it... why? To help fuel their MK of me because they have no other argument to speak of I reckon.

I saw a bunch of people agree or +1 with my questioning of Snowy. How about y'all join me on actually voting Snowy until Snowy provides some real answers?

Or stay on me and flip me – just promise me you'll vote Snowy next!

[snowy801]

@rdr thoughts on the above post?

@chaqa would appreciate your input as well, along with how you're reading Eden's game right now

[snowy801]

Alright fine you're all having fun in your Friday evening

I'll go actually read the thread

[Dousing]

I wanna tackle S&C but snowy’s fine as well I guess

##Vote snowy

[Chaqa]

@rdr thoughts on the above post?

@chaqa would appreciate your input as well, along with how you're reading Eden's game right now

Reading? Couldn't be me.

But yeah bruv, I think he's a bad hombre

[Bonatogether]

OK my case on Snowy is growing as Snowy is posting but ignoring my repeating questioning...

Because as far as I can tell they have no actual rationale for their hardlock of me as Mafia to share...



This is the best I can find:

When we flip you as Mafia, if I'm still alive, I'll say "boom" just for you.

Speaking of reasons why I actually believe something, I direct people to review this comment

In other words, they hardlock me as Mafia for using a definitive "when" instead of "if" inside a joke banter post with Bona.

Cool, cool..

But of course, how is is that any different from any of these (just a few I found after a cursory 2 min search):

Let's play a fun game many of you will enjoy:
- everyone post their case on Koala
- everyone vote Koala
- everyone post in advance of EOD what will be your learning when (if form your perspective) Koala flips Town
- flip me Town

My VCA, Bona's essay, your wierdness
Already voting you
You won't
We won't

koala i have a question for you

why are you scum

i'm going to read the OP

earliest setup reading mafia player

The best part is – the last one is by Snowy themselves!

So Snowy – you are a Mafia hardlock because you didn't say "if" when you said Bona is the earliest setup reading mafia player – riiiiight? You just stated it as a fact. Clearly, you can only know this from Mafia chat.



Like, people say different versions of essentially "you are Mafia" or "when you flip Mafia I'll be vindicated" all the time. Including Snowy themselves!

But somehow Snowy picks out the one instance I do it... why? To help fuel their MK of me because they have no other argument to speak of I reckon.

I saw a bunch of people agree or +1 with my questioning of Snowy. How about y'all join me on actually voting Snowy until Snowy provides some real answers?

Or stay on me and flip me – just promise me you'll vote Snowy next!
[/quote]
isn't the post by snowy clearly a reference to mafia the game?

this entire post falls under the same category as I documented of 'obfuscating through misrepresentation' as I understand it, just on a different (and easier) target

[snowy801]

@rdr thoughts on the above post?

@chaqa would appreciate your input as well, along with how you're reading Eden's game right now

Reading? Couldn't be me.

But yeah bruv, I think he's a bad hombre

Which one?

[snowy801]

You know it's pretty nice having only 66 pages to catch up on

I remember previous games where d1 was 150 pages

[Chaqa]

@rdr thoughts on the above post?

@chaqa would appreciate your input as well, along with how you're reading Eden's game right now

Reading? Couldn't be me.

But yeah bruv, I think he's a bad hombre

Which one?

Eden

[snowy801]

bona of the pool, what is your wisdom

[Bonatogether]

bona of the pool, what is your wisdom

koala is scum and eden probably is too

[Bonatogether]

koala because as outlined

eden has a persistent failure to towntell - only edenposting after i said he wasn't doing it

[KoalaAttack]

Wait, wait, wait.

Hold on a second here.

Ladies & Gentlemen, I present to you – The Case of Bona



For context, we are talking about this post of mine:

i think i'm pretty clearly cooler as i wasn't born in the previous millennium like a boomer

When we flip you as Mafia, if I'm still alive, I'll say "boom" just for you.

Speaking of reasons why I actually believe something, I direct people to review this comment

Which Snowy used as reason to hardlock me as Mafia.



And what is Bona's ultimate response to this entire discussion?

isn't the post by snowy clearly a reference to mafia the game?

this entire post falls under the same category as I documented of 'obfuscating through misrepresentation' as I understand it, just on a different (and easier) target

In other words, Bona is basically saying I am full of shit and Snowy is right.

OK... coolio... So, I'm full of shit and Snowy is right.

That means that my original post was indeed a Mafia claim, riiight?

Because I can only know that Bona is Mafia for sure if I'm Mafia myself, riiiight?

Yet it's the same Bona who is taking Snowy's side?



I am pretty sure there it at least one mafia caught here – and it ain't me.

Any of you logical types, please double-check my thinking above. Am I crazy?

[sweetandcool]

Wait, wait, wait.

Hold on a second here.

Ladies & Gentlemen, I present to you – The Case of Bona



For context, we are talking about this post of mine:

When we flip you as Mafia, if I'm still alive, I'll say "boom" just for you.

Speaking of reasons why I actually believe something, I direct people to review this comment

Which Snowy used as reason to hardlock me as Mafia.



And what is Bona's ultimate response to this entire discussion?

isn't the post by snowy clearly a reference to mafia the game?

this entire post falls under the same category as I documented of 'obfuscating through misrepresentation' as I understand it, just on a different (and easier) target

In other words, Bona is basically saying I am full of shit and Snowy is right.

OK... coolio... So, I'm full of shit and Snowy is right.

That means that my original post was indeed a Mafia claim, riiight?

Because I can only know that Bona is Mafia for sure if I'm Mafia myself, riiiight?

Yet it's the same Bona who is taking Snowy's side?



I am pretty sure there it at least one mafia caught here – and it ain't me.

Any of you logical types, please double-check my thinking above. Am I crazy?

I don't understand your reasoning here, sorry. I think you are either misunderstanding Bona or purposely misunderstanding him as he claims.

[KoalaAttack]

I don't understand your reasoning here, sorry. I think you are either misunderstanding Bona or purposely misunderstanding him as he claims.

Let me try again...

The entire discussion is about a post of mine that Snowy says proves I'm Mafia – because I say "when" Bona flips Mafia. Implying that only a Mafia know for sure that it's "when" and not "if".

I said this is ridiculous.

Bona then said that actually Snowy is right and I'm mis-representing Snowy.

But if Snowy is right, and I did claim Mafia, that makes Bona Mafia as well, by definition.

[Bonatogether]

OK my case on Snowy is growing as Snowy is posting but ignoring my repeating questioning...

Because as far as I can tell they have no actual rationale for their hardlock of me as Mafia to share...

i'm going to read the OP

earliest setup reading mafia player

The best part is – the last one is by Snowy themselves!

So Snowy – you are a Mafia hardlock because you didn't say "if" when you said Bona is the earliest setup reading mafia player – riiiiight? You just stated it as a fact. Clearly, you can only know this from Mafia chat.



Like, people say different versions of essentially "you are Mafia" or "when you flip Mafia I'll be vindicated" all the time. Including Snowy themselves!

if you had any critical thinking skills it'd be clearly evident this is the part i was referring to

[Bonatogether]

making me edit posts on phone is super cringe

[Bonatogether]

sweetandcool i appreciate your +1