MAFIA 79: The Price is Right! [GAME THREAD]

[Jamiet99uk]

I'm caught up.

##CALL GM:

Vote count, please?

[KoalaAttack]

Calling it now I'm getting miskilled D2.

Weak, I'm getting miskilled D1.

....by yourself?

Yes, since every living creature on this earth dies alone. I learned this from the ultimate scientific source of truth known as that Donnie Darko DVD that has been playing for a week which in turn comes from a The Limousines song.

But you can always join me to make it less lonely!

[Jamiet99uk]

Weak, I'm getting miskilled D1.

....by yourself?

Yes, since every living creature on this earth dies alone. I learned this from the ultimate scientific source of truth known as that Donnie Darko DVD that has been playing for a week which in turn comes from a The Limousines song.

But you can always join me to make it less lonely!

I'll play your little game, self-harming Gandalf.

##Vote KoalaAttackOfTheKillerTomatoes

[damo666]

it’s literally in the OP you noob

i didn't read that

Dumbslip.

Is title tinkering an offence?

[damo666]

##vote Bona contention

Just because.

@Koala please stop this self voting malarkey. It serves no purpose.

[Jamiet99uk]

i didn't read that

Dumbslip.

Is title tinkering an offence?

Not unless you're some kind of snowflake who's triggered by the smallest things.

Does that describe you, Damo?

[bozotheclown]

Not sure.

@Foxcastle what was your motivation?

1. To remind people of the time I was clever and won a game

2. To note that that kind of thing does happen. I wonder what Jamie's response would have been if someone else made the first vote on Koala and I made that point about another player—would he have said "Foxcastle, that was your play, and so it says nothing about Other Player"? I think he would have been more likely to say that it was a weak argument rather than non-applicable.

The thing Jamie didn't point out is that it's not a very good play in this game. Assuming they're both mafia, if Jamie knows he's bussing Koala, he's either the other goon, in which case he's killing off his only real teammate (this might be reasonable if he knows that the second goon is a great player), or he's the traitor, in which case he knows he doesn't know who his other teammate is and so it's a pretty big gamble.

So I think Jamie's response is actually kind of weird, but it's actually unlikely that the ploy I described is happening.

It should say...

Assuming they're both mafia, if Jamie knows he's bussing Koala, then he's the other goon, in which case he's killing off his only real teammate, or he's the traitor, in which case he knows that his other teammate doesn't know who he is and so it's a pretty big gamble (this might be reasonable if the second goon is a great player).

It seems like you are making some big assumptions about what the mafia decided. Or, you did not read the setup.

[bozotheclown]

i can't distinguish dousing and sweetandcool's posts apart

wtf how lol

they have wildly different personas and their names are nothing alike

New players = all the same

Also is it just me or is it obvious that the mafia wouldn't choose any mods

That does seem like their best option.

[Chaqa]

i can't distinguish dousing and sweetandcool's posts apart

wtf how lol

they have wildly different personas and their names are nothing alike

New players = all the same

Also is it just me or is it obvious that the mafia wouldn't choose any mods

I was just thinking this as I got caught up

[Chaqa]

lmao zoomers in shambles

Zoomers be like “what’s BBCode?”

[bozotheclown]

goons is the default, no bells or whistles role for mafia, so for a new player to open up early on d1 about mafia goons seems

it’s literally in the OP you noob

i didn't read that

I thought you were saying it was suspicious that sweetandcool assumed the mafia did not select to be PRs, but apparently not.

[Chaqa]

Calling it now I'm getting miskilled D2.

Why wait?

##vote ghug

[Foxcastle]

1. To remind people of the time I was clever and won a game

2. To note that that kind of thing does happen. I wonder what Jamie's response would have been if someone else made the first vote on Koala and I made that point about another player—would he have said "Foxcastle, that was your play, and so it says nothing about Other Player"? I think he would have been more likely to say that it was a weak argument rather than non-applicable.

The thing Jamie didn't point out is that it's not a very good play in this game. Assuming they're both mafia, if Jamie knows he's bussing Koala, he's either the other goon, in which case he's killing off his only real teammate (this might be reasonable if he knows that the second goon is a great player), or he's the traitor, in which case he knows he doesn't know who his other teammate is and so it's a pretty big gamble.

So I think Jamie's response is actually kind of weird, but it's actually unlikely that the ploy I described is happening.

It should say...

Assuming they're both mafia, if Jamie knows he's bussing Koala, then he's the other goon, in which case he's killing off his only real teammate, or he's the traitor, in which case he knows that his other teammate doesn't know who he is and so it's a pretty big gamble (this might be reasonable if the second goon is a great player).

It seems like you are making some big assumptions about what the mafia decided. Or, you did not read the setup.

Yeah, I was only thinking about the traitor's role, and not the scum team's options.

However, I find it odd that you'd shade this post and then go on to say in the very next post that you think the scenario I was describing (2 goons + traitor, not the specific bussing tactic) was their best option.

[Jamiet99uk]

Assuming they're both mafia, if Jamie knows he's bussing Koala, then he's the other goon, in which case he's killing off his only real teammate, or he's the traitor, in which case he knows that his other teammate doesn't know who he is and so it's a pretty big gamble (this might be reasonable if the second goon is a great player).

It seems like you are making some big assumptions about what the mafia decided. Or, you did not read the setup.

Yeah, I was only thinking about the traitor's role, and not the scum team's options.

However, I find it odd that you'd shade this post and then go on to say in the very next post that you think the scenario I was describing (2 goons + traitor, not the specific bussing tactic) was their best option.

I find that odd as well.

This is all very interesting.

[rdrivera2005]

dousing have you played these types of games before?

~~~

sweetandcool seems genuine enough but it’s concerning a subject that is not alignment indicative

Yes, many times

this and among us. I don't play any other game except town of salem and among us

P.S bonatogether sus

Bona is always sus.

With the bot being offline I will be even less present as at work I use mainly the bot.

[rdrivera2005]

Calling it now I'm getting miskilled D2.

You.are never misskilled...

[rdrivera2005]

So uhh... am I actually gonna get lynched here or are we just playin' around?

What do you think? Do the people voting for you seem earnest in their pursuit?

No, but its not like mobs are the most rational bunch

I like this new guy, let's kill someone annoying and not him today.

[damo666]

Dumbslip.

Is title tinkering an offence?

Not unless you're some kind of snowflake who's triggered by the smallest things.

Does that describe you, Damo?

What do you think?

[damo666]

What do you think? Do the people voting for you seem earnest in their pursuit?

No, but its not like mobs are the most rational bunch

I like this new guy, let's kill someone annoying and not him today.

I agree. Bona or Koala.

[President Eden]

No, but its not like mobs are the most rational bunch

I like this new guy, let's kill someone annoying and not him today.

I agree. Bona or Koala.

What if we killed scum instead