"it ignores all the elimination game that he performed great in"
Which ones were those? 99 - one and done.
2000 - one and done
2001 - no playoffs;
2002 - one and done; blown out 41-0 by your Jets
2003 - conference title game; had a bye, played one game
2004 - one and done; had a bye, scored a whopping 3
in playoff loss
2005 - one and done
2006 - super bowl win
2007 - one and done
2008 - one and done
2009 - superbowl appearance
2010 - one and done
What is remarkable is how many seasons the Colts were the most dominant team in the league and yet blew it in the playoffs.