"You, or Vecna. Or Flood. Hell floodgates killed 2 scum."
mhm, PR's did a good job, though doc mostly later in the game. Cop reads won the game. Floodgates played good, but I don't think it was the best play here. Jamie and Chaqa were shots most people would take, so I'm not sure if that counts for him, though he was off radar for the mafia and kept his calm, maybe it is. And if we count "goddess" for that, we should also remember Maniac. And ghug (though his nk was mostly because mafia feared his lategame).
for town, I have two people where I want to give my thoughts into:
-) brain obviously, his day 1 was I think one of the game deciding moves. He could improve his behaviour in his tunneling from what I've seen, consider not only one of his theories, but all of his thoughts at the same time. Maybe I'm wrong, but I think if you had combined your theories and looked at the overall picture, it might've been even better.
-) I don't know if you think so too, but after his day one, I think DemonRHK improved strongly in his play. His reads and logic were good, he was the one that noticed that the roleblocker wasn't here and played solidly after he got on his feet. Even when other townies suspected him for being scum. He was relevant and might be the reason why town got 2 scums instead of just 1.
"Kaka played really great as scum. "
Thanks, but I've noticed some mistakes I made, some subpar game and maybe I shouldn't be in charge of the nightkills (like on the last day). I was ok to good in hiding, or at least surviving, but not so great at manipulating. So yeah, thanks for the mention, but I don't think it was a great game for me. It was very enjoyable and I had fun, but I have much to improve there. (well ... at least I can brag of my 100% scum voting :p )