Mafia 46 - Ace Attorney - GAME THREAD

[damo666]

what convinced you of this?

why do you think scum roleblocked you?

he wasn't roleblocked

same question for you damo. why do you think scum roleblocked you? i'm sorry if you've answered this but please answer this again

Because they suspected I was BA I assume.

[Durga]

Why can't it be RBd VT (me) v BA fake claiming RB (Connor)?

Though I think Connor far more likely to be scum than BA.

Unless of course you have just BA slipped et!

Why would the BA fake claim an RB? The fact that you even hypothesized this is concerning. I want to hear exactly what you think the benefits of BA fake claiming are please

I think it unlikely but was demonstrating to et that it is at least possible. One motivation could be that BA connor seeing my claim and thinking he can beat me in 1to1 can become a quasi cleared BA. A very powerful position as BA.

Uhhhh is this a scum slip lmfao

[Durga]

I'm pretty sure that was a scum slip

[damo666]

Towards the end of day I became more and more convinced they were both scum so I didn't feel I needed to say anything.

what convinced you of this?

why do you think scum roleblocked you?

I think that Fox's voting for himself maneuver was an attempt to take teacon down with him, making them both seem scum rather than just Fox.

I don't really know. Apparently at the beginning of D4 I was one of the BA suspects, and since I've been aligning myself somewhat firmly against (what I believe to be) scum, then they thought that I would end up killing Mafia. I don't know who they had in mind though, since teacon has been cleared, i trusted Balki and I hadn't even mentioned Foxcastle before today.

I really don't understand this reply.

[Squigs44]

Why can't it be RBd VT (me) v BA fake claiming RB (Connor)?

Though I think Connor far more likely to be scum than BA.

Unless of course you have just BA slipped et!

Why would the BA fake claim an RB? The fact that you even hypothesized this is concerning. I want to hear exactly what you think the benefits of BA fake claiming are please

I think it unlikely but was demonstrating to et that it is at least possible. One motivation could be that BA connor seeing my claim and thinking he can beat me in 1to1 can become a quasi cleared BA. A very powerful position as BA.

He's only cleared if you're scum

[Squigs44]

I'm pretty sure that was a scum slip

Yes, I do believe it was

[et]

Rip Teacon.
BA, please NK Connor or damo.
Those 2 are obviously not BA.
It's not bad choice for you.

Why can't it be RBd VT (me) v BA fake claiming RB (Connor)?

Though I think Connor far more likely to be scum than BA.

Unless of course you have just BA slipped et!

If BA claimed fake roleblocked, Mafia knows who is BA.
BA killed Balki.
So, I thought BA don't claim fake roleblocked.

[connorcompton]

Just had a look and fair enough, there isn't really. I guess my mind inflated these comments from Nephthys.

So the roleblock was between Flav and connor???

Balki probably thought Flav's reaction to Balki claiming BA was evidence that Flav was BA.

Imagine if connor was actually the BA...

did connor have a scum read or any read on trprado?

He moved off him with 3 mins to play D1

I actually think there's a case in here almost

Why does connor make sense?

Why connor over peter?

Who do you think as BA and why are they above connor?

Also not quite sure what that last sentence means.

[damo666]

Why would the BA fake claim an RB? The fact that you even hypothesized this is concerning. I want to hear exactly what you think the benefits of BA fake claiming are please

I think it unlikely but was demonstrating to et that it is at least possible. One motivation could be that BA connor seeing my claim and thinking he can beat me in 1to1 can become a quasi cleared BA. A very powerful position as BA.

He's only cleared if you're scum

Oh yeah! Didn't think that through properly did I! It's Durga putting me under pressure!

[connorcompton]

Towards the end of day I became more and more convinced they were both scum so I didn't feel I needed to say anything.

what convinced you of this?

why do you think scum roleblocked you?

he wasn't roleblocked

That's actually a really good point, damo! How did we not see this?

[Durga]

I think it unlikely but was demonstrating to et that it is at least possible. One motivation could be that BA connor seeing my claim and thinking he can beat me in 1to1 can become a quasi cleared BA. A very powerful position as BA.

He's only cleared if you're scum

Oh yeah! Didn't think that through properly did I! It's Durga putting me under pressure!

I made you scum slip under pressure? That's what I call solid town skills.

[damo666]

Rip Teacon.
BA, please NK Connor or damo.
Those 2 are obviously not BA.
It's not bad choice for you.

Why can't it be RBd VT (me) v BA fake claiming RB (Connor)?

Though I think Connor far more likely to be scum than BA.

Unless of course you have just BA slipped et!

If BA claimed fake roleblocked, Mafia knows who is BA.
BA killed Balki.
So, I thought BA don't claim fake roleblocked.

How?

[et]

Please think well. If that is Town(roleblocked)vBA(fake roleblocked), mafia can roleblock BA from next night.
BA don't think this is possible.
But I think that is unlikely.

[connorcompton]

I think it unlikely but was demonstrating to et that it is at least possible. One motivation could be that BA connor seeing my claim and thinking he can beat me in 1to1 can become a quasi cleared BA. A very powerful position as BA.

He's only cleared if you're scum

Oh yeah! Didn't think that through properly did I! It's Durga putting me under pressure!

Sure.

[damo666]

He's only cleared if you're scum

Oh yeah! Didn't think that through properly did I! It's Durga putting me under pressure!

I made you scum slip under pressure? That's what I call solid town skills.

Wasn't a scumslip. Just didn't think it through properly. Bad townplay. Soz.

[Durga]

Why can't it be RBd VT (me) v BA fake claiming RB (Connor)?

Though I think Connor far more likely to be scum than BA.

Unless of course you have just BA slipped et!

If BA claimed fake roleblocked, Mafia knows who is BA.
BA killed Balki.
So, I thought BA don't claim fake roleblocked.

How?

Damo has really been searching for that BA lol.

Ok no way damo is rb or anything important. Fox might be something important.

[Durga]

I'm trying to figure out how a townie being roleblocked would assume their death would quasi cleared the BA but I just can't see that.

[Squigs44]

Oh yeah! Didn't think that through properly did I! It's Durga putting me under pressure!

I made you scum slip under pressure? That's what I call solid town skills.

Wasn't a scumslip. Just didn't think it through properly. Bad townplay. Soz.

But your comment was working on the assumption you are scum. If you're town and you didn't think it through, why is it working on the assumption you are scum?

[connorcompton]

As for other scum reads, not quite sure. 4 remaining, and I have damo, and fairly sure on Fox. The other two are either hiding where I have previously trusted (Most likely Chippe or et) or on a current null (Percy and peterlund). I think Flavius and ND are the most possible BAs, and the only other 'in question' players left is Squigs, who I think is quite likely town. (I find it a bit weird it's taken the Mafia this long to NK him though)

[Durga]

In defense of Squigs, there's a long list of players mafia still need to kill before he's up