M1007 — "Mafia, She Wrote" Game Thread

[xorxes]

Scum!xorxes, last game:

bozo seems like his methodical self, but that's not too hard to fake as scum. Could be.

damo, this game:

Bozo his usual logical self. Impossible to guess his alignment.

I'm really surprised that nobody else is at all bothered by this.

I can't see it as mere coincidence. I can come up perhaps with an innocent explanation but it's certainly not the one damo gave, that "we think alike".

If we lynch anyone other than damo today I don't understand what you all are thinking.

I have a dentist appointment in half an hour and may or may not be back for EOD.

[xorxes]

We should honestly just lynch xorxes he's totally scum

You townread me last game when I was scum and now you scumread me when I'm town to compensate?

[Durga]

We should honestly just lynch xorxes he's totally scum

You townread me last game when I was scum and now you scumread me when I'm town to compensate?

I never town read you beyond D1 last day

[teacon7]

Followups for vash:

What do you think of my "policy" of a D1 lynch pool of low-commitment posters?

What does espresso sound like to you rn? too polite? not pretty enough?

[MoscowFleet]

@teacon I’ve made a couple posts on vapour, and he hasn’t improved much if you ask me.

Take his most recent post, where he states he has kept pushing for a Percy lynch, when in fact all he’s previously said about Percy is that he’d be “up for his lynch” with no reasoning. The early vote on him was a pressure vote. Vapour also never mentioned EMC as a scumread, yet apparently thinks he’s scum, again with no reasoning. The two scumreads that pop up out of nowhere are you and damo, but he says although he scumreads these two he won’t vote them? Like overall he’s not making a lot of sense.

Overall very hedgy play and if you read his posts it seems like he’s having trouble deciding who to scumread, which seems like a very scummy problem to have.

[rdrivera2005]

Scum!xorxes, last game:

bozo seems like his methodical self, but that's not too hard to fake as scum. Could be.

damo, this game:

Bozo his usual logical self. Impossible to guess his alignment.

I'm really surprised that nobody else is at all bothered by this.

I can't see it as mere coincidence. I can come up perhaps with an innocent explanation but it's certainly not the one damo gave, that "we think alike".

If we lynch anyone other than damo today I don't understand what you all are thinking.

I have a dentist appointment in half an hour and may or may not be back for EOD.

Damo is the second wagon now, so I would not say that "nobody else bothered".

[MoscowFleet]

@xorxes is that all on damo, that he said a similar sentence to you from when you were scum? Although I agree I don’t really like his style, it seems like the way he always plays.

[teacon7]

@teacon I’ve made a couple posts on vapour, and he hasn’t improved much if you ask me.

Take his most recent post, where he states he has kept pushing for a Percy lynch, when in fact all he’s previously said about Percy is that he’d be “up for his lynch” with no reasoning. The early vote on him was a pressure vote. Vapour also never mentioned EMC as a scumread, yet apparently thinks he’s scum, again with no reasoning. The two scumreads that pop up out of nowhere are you and damo, but he says although he scumreads these two he won’t vote them? Like overall he’s not making a lot of sense.

Overall very hedgy play and if you read his posts it seems like he’s having trouble deciding who to scumread, which seems like a very scummy problem to have.

ok, fair. tbf, I think he started a percy wagon a while back hoping to pressure percy to play more.
There are other people who are voting with less reason than vapor on percy.
Do a reread on vapor and lmk what you think.

[xorxes]

preparing the noose for these candidates:
damo
e.m.c
Percy

Place your vote on damo then? Percy could be scum too but the evidence is much more flimsy.

[xorxes]

@xorxes is that all on damo, that he said a similar sentence to you from when you were scum? Although I agree I don’t really like his style, it seems like the way he always plays.

He copies people's reads from other games as town? Or do you think the same wording was purely coincidental?

[xorxes]

@teacon I’ve made a couple posts on vapour, and he hasn’t improved much if you ask me.

Take his most recent post, where he states he has kept pushing for a Percy lynch, when in fact all he’s previously said about Percy is that he’d be “up for his lynch” with no reasoning. The early vote on him was a pressure vote. Vapour also never mentioned EMC as a scumread, yet apparently thinks he’s scum, again with no reasoning. The two scumreads that pop up out of nowhere are you and damo, but he says although he scumreads these two he won’t vote them? Like overall he’s not making a lot of sense.

Overall very hedgy play and if you read his posts it seems like he’s having trouble deciding who to scumread, which seems like a very scummy problem to have.

ok, fair. tbf, I think he started a percy wagon a while back hoping to pressure percy to play more.
There are other people who are voting with less reason than vapor on percy.
Do a reread on vapor and lmk what you think.

teacon, what was your take on damo? You probably said it already but I haven't been able to read everything yet.

[teacon7]

I'm really surprised that nobody else is at all bothered by this.

I can't see it as mere coincidence. I can come up perhaps with an innocent explanation but it's certainly not the one damo gave, that "we think alike".

If we lynch anyone other than damo today I don't understand what you all are thinking.

I have a dentist appointment in half an hour and may or may not be back for EOD.

He's on my radar. His are all somewhat indecisive reads, not just the one on you. Last game he was more decisive. tbf, it's D1.

What do you think of my "let's policy a low-investment participation-poster" idea? it's not lurker policy, because low-posting is scum indicative.

dentist appts suck. gl;hf.

[rdrivera2005]

@teacon I’ve made a couple posts on vapour, and he hasn’t improved much if you ask me.

Take his most recent post, where he states he has kept pushing for a Percy lynch, when in fact all he’s previously said about Percy is that he’d be “up for his lynch” with no reasoning. The early vote on him was a pressure vote. Vapour also never mentioned EMC as a scumread, yet apparently thinks he’s scum, again with no reasoning. The two scumreads that pop up out of nowhere are you and damo, but he says although he scumreads these two he won’t vote them? Like overall he’s not making a lot of sense.

Overall very hedgy play and if you read his posts it seems like he’s having trouble deciding who to scumread, which seems like a very scummy problem to have.

Moscow, have you played with Vapor before?

[Durga]

Can we push the deadline back

[teacon7]

teacon, what was your take on damo? You probably said it already but I haven't been able to read everything yet.

he's hedgy, which is a second to third tier lynch offense for D1. read my post on pg27. for the rationale.

[ND]

##VOTE DAMO

he is a good second choice for me.

[ND]

hm. nope. on re-read, Vash deserves to be on that list too.

http://mafia.peterlund.se/e/web/msgs?g= ... taNeurotic

He's mostly just harping on ND for playing lightning rod early d1. it's the "look, an easy wagon" approach.


@ND
@Durga
what do you think of Vash so far?

I've never been a huge fan of Vashta going all the way back to the beginning. I haven't seen enough yet he has barely done anything so far. Why I got him as null.

[Durga]

Scum!xorxes, last game:

bozo seems like his methodical self, but that's not too hard to fake as scum. Could be.

damo, this game:

Bozo his usual logical self. Impossible to guess his alignment.

I'm really surprised that nobody else is at all bothered by this.

I can't see it as mere coincidence. I can come up perhaps with an innocent explanation but it's certainly not the one damo gave, that "we think alike".

If we lynch anyone other than damo today I don't understand what you all are thinking.

I have a dentist appointment in half an hour and may or may not be back for EOD.

I don't get it. Both statements can be made as either alignment. It's just true about bozo.

[rdrivera2005]

##VOTE DAMO

he is a good second choice for me.

Now it's tied. We might have an interesting EOD.

[teacon7]

teacon, what was your take on damo? You probably said it already but I haven't been able to read everything yet.

he's hedgy, which is a second to third tier lynch offense for D1. read my post on pg27. for the rationale.

by second-to-third-tier... I mean... we're all kinda unsure on D1, because we don't know anything yet.

i'd point out that your point about similar phrasing has some merit, but might be a bit of projection. "hey, that's what I say when I'm scum! therefore, he's scum!" It's similar phrasing, but maybe temper the amplitude of your read since he might not play scum the same way you do.