MAFIA 39 - GAME THREAD

[Durga]

Durga is town

I just explained why she isnt

This happens every game, best to ignore him when he gets to this point.

[Tom Bombadil]

Durga is town

I just explained why she isnt

No. You just quoted messages and then said Durga is scum.

[brainbomb]

Y2k writes- yea cannon holder should shoot squiggs.
Durga writes "Now were talking"

This implies durga agrees with y2k statement.

Then durga never again considers shooting squiggs
Never even posts a single read on squiggs
At EOD as squiggs is at 6 she writes "this sucks"

Then squiggs busses her

[brainbomb]

Simple.

Game solved

[brainbomb]

Last 2 scum is y2k-durga

[Durga]

I can't stop laughing.

Can repair kit please choose bb's item and see if he's legit. It feels like he's breaking down, which is something scum should be doing about now.

[xorxes]

I don't think Squigs would have lied about the Foam Hammer because he risked being immediately counterclaimed if town had it, and it's not some item that Mafia are desperate to find out who has it, so we can probably assume that was his real item.

[worcej]

Y2k writes- yea cannon holder should shoot squiggs.
Durga writes "Now were talking"

This implies durga agrees with y2k statement.

Then durga never again considers shooting squiggs
Never even posts a single read on squiggs
At EOD as squiggs is at 6 she writes "this sucks"

Then squiggs busses her

I tend to agree with this assessment on Durga - I felt like the shot was delayed for and I did find it funny that Squiggs was not included into the analysis. The distancing seems intentional more than coincidental.

[Durga]

ya because i publicly post "this sucks" as my scum partner (who i would know is scum) is about to be lynched

because i claim my cannon and shoot chaqa with it when i could have shot anyone secretly, especially someone i thought was a legit good town player rather than fucking chaqa

[flash2015]

Last 2 scum is y2k-durga

I can see the Durga argument (I will join that wagon)...but why y2k?

[worcej]

ya because i publicly post "this sucks" as my scum partner (who i would know is scum) is about to be lynched

because i claim my cannon and shoot chaqa with it when i could have shot anyone secretly, especially someone i thought was a legit good town player rather than fucking chaqa

Using mobile so no bot, but you soft-claimed it early and were slow as crap to pick a target until you picked one you liked - it wasnt a leading wagon which would’ve made more sense.

The cannon can 100% be used as a way for town-cred and hide as the game goes on.

[Tom Bombadil]

...

[Durga]

Ok lynch me then, you guys are too dumb to fuck with

[brainbomb]

Brainbomb - Mr Investigator Townclear and frontrunner for town mvp with that scan
Bozotheclown - RIP
Chaqa - Inactive. Null
Damo666 - Seems himself. And by that I mean useless. Although he seems to be talking more than usual this game. Slight townlean.
DemonRHK - A lot of idle chat during N0. Makes a post potentially setting up a scumread on Flash, then apologizes. Finally gets around to posting reads on people, and they seem reachy. Slight scum


Durga - Claims cannon and pledges to shoot it. Retracts, no cannon shot, then reclaims. Whether scum or town, was probably waiting for a better shot. The playstyle seems pretty genuine though, hard to see scum be this ballsy. Slight town pending what happens with the cannon.


Flash2015 - Starts with a joke vote during night. Comments on Peterbot. Another joke post about tradition. Shows up in time to shoot MoscowFleet, then leaves. If Flash didn’t shoot MF, I would probably be voting Flash. He has not done anything really at all. But it looks like he is just lurking, reading the thread, and chiming in when he wants to. Maybe Flash is scum who realized that MF was going to die anyway and wanted the towncred of shooting him. Flash, please contribute more or else I might actually vote you. Slight scum.
Ghug - My favorite player to read because I cant read him worth crap. Seems pretty standard ghug this game, if maybe a little more reserved than previous games. Slight town.
MoscowFleet - Scum
ND - Didnt respond to my question N0, deferred all effort to D1. Still hasn’t put in any effort. Did this last game though and was town. Slight scum.
Rdrivera2005 - Has made some good comments, pointed out where other people made errors, helpful to town. Townlean, but this is exactly how I felt about rdrivera the last two games.
Snowy801 - Hasn’t done anything this game except joke. Why do we have so many inactive people this game? Slight scum.
Squigs44 - Town
Tom Bombadil - Starting post has two jokes, and a comment about xorxes cannon plan. Then reverses his thoughts on xorxes cannon plan pretty easily. Votes ND with no explanation. I don’t think Tom has really done anything to help town, and the vibes I am getting from him are off. Scumlean.
Vecna - Pretty standard Vecna. Active, pushing people, makes sense, seems genuine. Town.
Worcej - Weird reaction to BB’s claim followed by a bad answer when questioned. Basically claims armor at the beginning of the day. Why he would do this under either alignment IDK. Scumlean.
Xorxes - His cannon plan is probably NAI. Has been very talkative, but mostly about mechanics. Has gotten better lately, but still seems pretty meh. Null.
Y2kjbk - Gets off to a real fast start, and has been active, which is solidly in his town meta. Town

Top two scum are Tom and Worcej, with the third being one of Chaqa, Snowy, ND.

[brainbomb]

Y2kjbk - Gets off to a real fast start, and has been active, which is solidly in his town meta. Town

[brainbomb]

Squoggs has barely ever played with y2k

[flash2015]

I can't stop laughing.

Can repair kit please choose bb's item and see if he's legit. It feels like he's breaking down, which is something scum should be doing about now.

There was only one detective kit and it had to be owned by town.

[Tom Bombadil]

Squoggs has barely ever played with y2k

Yeah. Which means he made up reads to sound genuine. I don't think that incriminates y2k at all

[DemonRHK]

damo is my top scumread at the moment.

He called out brain for leaving ghug back to squigs and then hopped on with two minutes to go no explanation.

The lack of a counterpush leads me to believe:

- One of the hard lurks is scum, ND, Vecna, snowy/yavu, rdrivera maybe?

OR

- It was scum v scum and Tom is as well.

I'm more inclined to point one. Squigs went at Tom hard in my defense for some reason. I owe you an apology Tom.

---

The Durga thoughts are interesting. I don't see her as scum currently, but she held that shot forever. I think if she's scum she hipfires me when I dare her to though.

---

The repair, if town, should be used on the detective kit. Guns can hit town or town armor.

We'll need to be careful with voting tomorrow. There is a reason I wasn't on a wagon at all for 45 hours.

---

damo is top suspect. Most likely accomplice is Vecna or ND
(Interesting sidenote: In his readlist on p20, everyone he puts a divider between has a => EXCEPT ND, who has a -)

[Durga]

What about ND-ghug being the final two?