webdiplomacy.net

Durga wrote: ↑

Thu Sep 06, 2018 11:01 pm

Good I don't have time for this game so if they wanna waste their time killing me and my cannon they can go for it.

##call gm I can't live fire the cannon at night?

CANNON - A firearm which makes a loud noise and fires a cannonball which will kill the target. May be fired night or day. PM both GMs in the format ##SHOOT [TARGET]. At night it adjudicates at EoN. During the day the shot will be adjudicated as soon as the GM sees your message.

Oh, I thought you meant a legitimate scumread as opposed to a feeling. Carry on.

I have no cannon. Shoot Xorxes

God Jamie I thought someone died, easy with the caps.

bozotheclown
Brainbomb
Chaqa.
damo666
DemonRHK
Durga
flash2015
ghug
MoscowFleet
ND.
rdrivera2005
snowy801
Squigs44
Tom Bombadil
Vecna
worcej
xorxes
y2kjbk

damo666 wrote: ↑

Thu Sep 06, 2018 11:06 pm

I have no cannon. Shoot Xorxes

Why do you think it was necessary to tell us that, and why do you want Xorxes shot?

To get some action going scumbag

brainbomb wrote: ↑

Thu Sep 06, 2018 11:03 pm

Squiggs is my first actual scumread so far btw

But I can't vote for him until D2. Can't buck tradition...

...that doesn't really answer either question.

I know. So what?

Squigs44 wrote: ↑

Thu Sep 06, 2018 11:01 pm

Durga wrote: ↑

Thu Sep 06, 2018 10:31 pm

Alright, I think we should maximize info out of this night. And so I claim that I have a cannon. Now vote for who you think I should shoot

It looks like Durga is claiming more to get info and less because she actually has a cannon. Although I could be wrong. I hope she really doesn't have the cannon though, because that gives mafia info. I do think a potential cannon vote might be useful even if the cannon holder doesn't shoot, which I don't think they should.

t

I'd shoot squigs for this, this logic seems to hard assume Durga is town without being explicit about it. A small slip potentially.

Xorxes plan is absolute dogshit. Claiming guns reduces the PR pool and increases odds of finding docs and the 1shot cop guy for scum.

Ill post later.

y2kjbk wrote: ↑

Thu Sep 06, 2018 11:14 pm

Squigs44 wrote: ↑

Thu Sep 06, 2018 11:01 pm

Durga wrote: ↑

Thu Sep 06, 2018 10:31 pm

Alright, I think we should maximize info out of this night. And so I claim that I have a cannon. Now vote for who you think I should shoot

It looks like Durga is claiming more to get info and less because she actually has a cannon. Although I could be wrong. I hope she really doesn't have the cannon though, because that gives mafia info. I do think a potential cannon vote might be useful even if the cannon holder doesn't shoot, which I don't think they should.

t

I'd shoot squigs for this, this logic seems to hard assume Durga is town without being explicit about it. A small slip potentially.

Now we're talking.

So, I repeat shoot Xorxes

Vecna is town

Could someone do me a favour and summarize Damo's play in previous games?

xorxes wrote: ↑

Thu Sep 06, 2018 9:40 pm

y2kjbk wrote: ↑

Thu Sep 06, 2018 9:32 pm

I think it's a bad idea for cannon shots to be rushed on behalf of the town before we know anything. I could potentially embrace the town collectively utilizing the cannons after EON1.

But forcing the hand of Mafia is good too. If the Mafia has a cannon they will keep it for as long as possible because they will want to shoot claears with it. If they don't shoot who we tell them now we will know the cannon is with Mafia and eventually we will know who has what item so that holding the shot to shoot a clear will cost them.

I do not know if claiming the cannons was a good idea with the RB and thief acting before the cannon at EON, but since Durga has already claimed a cannon, I think the other cannon should claim and we should vote on the targets for N0, to maximize the information gained.

ghug: the five potential clears are the two nurses, the electroshield, the birthday card and the detective, they can only be town.

brainbomb: if the Mafia roleblock and kill the cannon holder that could mean they may be trying to protect the target we selected, that would also be somewhat informative. And the cannon holder is not one of the potential clears anyway, so it's not a bad NK for town, better than them NKing a potential clear. Cannon holders should not be afraid of being NK'd. It means the detective won't be roleblocked and killed before giving us their scan.

I think both cannon holders need to claim for the plan to be most effective, because forcing a scum to claim if they have a cannon is an important part of it. We will most likely find out who has what item at some point by process of elimination, and then if they had a cannon and didn't claim it could help us catch them. If they are forced to claim their gun they are less likely to be able to use it effectively.

GM NOTE:

Since I have been asked to clarify, the ARMOUR does protect against the NK as well as shots from a CANNON.

Remember the Armour, like other items, works only once. If someone with Armour was both shot at, and targeted by the NK, on the same night, they would still die.

For that to even work youd need a massclaim if scum had a gun.

Otherwise theyd stay silent and have no reason to claim