MAFIA 39 - GAME THREAD

[ghug]

Ghug had the replacement head. Couldve told a scum buddy to steal it from him.

Why wouldn't I just keep it for myself and let my scumbuddy steal from someone else?

[Durga]

Hey when did y2k get good at this game. I remember him being really horrible, but I think he's solid rn

[Tom Bombadil]

that seems terribly contrived.

I feel you are creating theories and then looking at info, rather than the other way around.

[flash2015]

She knew she was hitting town. We gave her an easy excuse to take out Chaka. It all gives her town cred...whilst achieving scum objectives.

Again, Xorxes was helping with the plan, trying to force out the second cannon holder (me).

Why would should claim cannon D1 if she were scum?

Why would I take out Chaqa?

Because you couldn't be blamed when he rolled town.

[Durga]

Aight, flash is officially in the ignore section

[brainbomb]

Ghug had the replacement head. Couldve told a scum buddy to steal it from him.

Why wouldn't I just keep it for myself and let my scumbuddy steal from someone else?

I dont have an answer to this

[brainbomb]

Ghug your only scumread so far was durga.

[ghug]

I still don't really like the Chaqa shot in light of his apparent townslip, but I feel like she'll give us plenty more to go on if we wait a day or two. Our cannons both look pretty lame on their other merits, but they're still way more likely to claim them as town then as scum.

[flash2015]

that seems terribly contrived.

I feel you are creating theories and then looking at info, rather than the other way around.

Are you talking to me? Why is it contrived? Xorxes push to out the other cannon holder didn't make sense to me before. Now it does.

[ghug]

Than*

[xorxes]

Ghug had the replacement head. Couldve told a scum buddy to steal it from him.

Why would they waste the thief stealing from a teammate?

In any case, he could still be scum and the thief be town, that he had his head stolen tells us nothing of his alignment.

[Vecna]

thieving goes before the kill. thats why bozo died maybe?

steal bozos item. kill him. have ghugh claim to revert suspicion off of him.

would require both the thief and that item to be on scum though.

[brainbomb]

Are you scumreading ghug veccy?

[y2kjbk]

It’s silly to think scum would risk taking very bad actions for their team just to gain some towncred. If either flash or Durga are scum, they threw away their guns early and put their scum game at a serious disadvantage. If they start trying to lurk and skate by without further participation, then I’d entertain the possibility that they were seeking towncred with their cannons.

[Vecna]

I mean, scum randomly hitting one of the most usefull items with a n0 uninformed thief seems pretty lucky. noone claimed the steal yet, right?

either way, I dont really have any other real reasons to scumread ghug. he will remain one of the persons i suck at reading.

##vote ghug

[Vecna]

and ##unvote

just to fullfill the rquirement to avoid modkills

[Durga]

Vecna stop playing

[ghug]

Brain, if I'm scum, I was most likely robbed by a town thief. Likewise, if someone with the head flips scum, I think I should look fairly good.

I've scumread Squiggles and commented on flash as well, and I've pushed for the lurkers. I'm far more interested in getting townreads right now (hence the annoyance at chaqa's death in spite of his uselessness). I feel good about xorxes and y2k and lean townish on damo, RHK, and worcej.

[Vecna]

also, scum using their guns in this setup seems really terrible. really really terrible. im quite certain durga as scum could easily survive and have the gun actually further her wincon. why the fuck shoot chaqa of all people on day2. same applies to flash, no reason to shoot there, even though he did shoot really quickly.

[Vecna]

Vecna stop playing

what are you trying to say here do?