MAFIA 39 - GAME THREAD

[brainbomb]

Im with vecna on this lets not start helping scum during a night phase to find ways to nullify towns best roles.

[brainbomb]

Is scum guaranteed to hold the theif item? Or did you just assume that? Either way if the theft option is in scums hands as bozo just said then durgas cannon will be theirs anyway

[xorxes]

It looks like Durga is claiming more to get info and less because she actually has a cannon. Although I could be wrong. I hope she really doesn't have the cannon though, because that gives mafia info. I do think a potential cannon vote might be useful even if the cannon holder doesn't shoot, which I don't think they should.

I don't think you're considering the possibility that the cannon is in scum's hands. If they have the option to act on our vote or not then they can explain away their not shooting who we voted for if it happens to be a scum.

[y2kjbk]

There are no scum-guaranteed items.

[bozotheclown]

@bozo

I hope you dont take my request to shoot you too personal. Its actually less about you and more about how every freaking game ppl try to lynch you. Our player pool cant read you and I feel like we should solve that issue. I cant ask everyone on here to get better. I can ask that you do your best- which you do. I feel like your scumgame is very obvious but thats just me. Feel free to explain why shooting you is bad for town. (Its not) but do explain

Assuming the premise of your argument is accurate, there would be more information in me getting mislynched later than getting shot now.

[brainbomb]

Not really bozo. Mostly ive seen you get mislynched late game where town ends up losing because it was stupid to lynch you and instead of learning they proceed to self cannibalize

[brainbomb]

Although TRprado isnt playing so theres hope for town.

[brainbomb]

Ive said enough for tonight :). Lets kill squiggs or bozo.

See ya tomorrow fam. MAYBEEEE

Go Falcons

[Squigs44]

It looks like Durga is claiming more to get info and less because she actually has a cannon. Although I could be wrong. I hope she really doesn't have the cannon though, because that gives mafia info. I do think a potential cannon vote might be useful even if the cannon holder doesn't shoot, which I don't think they should.

I don't think you're considering the possibility that the cannon is in scum's hands. If they have the option to act on our vote or not then they can explain away their not shooting who we voted for if it happens to be a scum.

I don't think scum would claim if they had a cannon. There is no incentive. I also don't think they would fake claim which is why I am town reading Durga.

[xorxes]

For that to even work youd need a massclaim if scum had a gun.

Otherwise theyd stay silent and have no reason to claim

There will be a massclaim at some point. Then if they stayed silent they will have to make up some other item and they could be caught because of that.

[xorxes]

Is scum guaranteed to hold the theif item? Or did you just assume that? Either way if the theft option is in scums hands as bozo just said then durgas cannon will be theirs anyway

And then when we find out who the thief is we catch scum.

[bozotheclown]

Xorxes plan is absolute dogshit. Claiming guns reduces the PR pool and increases odds of finding docs and the 1shot cop guy for scum.

Ill post later.

I do not think this is a good argument against the cannons claiming, the doc and cop items are one use only. Also, Durga has already claimed to have a cannon, so that must be taken into consideration.

[y2kjbk]

hmmm i wouldn't shoot squigs anymore, he has a good response for town-reading Durga

[Squigs44]

Tom flip-flopped after one comment by Xorxes and got defensive after about one page. Scummy.

[MoscowFleet]

Go Falcons

Amen.

[worcej]

Ive said enough for tonight :). Lets kill squiggs or bozo.

See ya tomorrow fam. MAYBEEEE

Go Falcons

Go Falcons indeed!

[snowy801]

you know I sat through 2 hours of sexual harassment training?
drhk reminded me of one of the stupider clips we had to watch

also why am I in a game where "love heart" is a power
I was not informed of this

[Chaqa]

Watching the Eagles game. I'll try to get caught up afterward or tomorrow morning. GO EAGLES!

[ND]

Like the game starts at N1 so I am inclined to do a full-assessment start of D1. I don't really have much to say or add to a game that starts in the night phase. It's more of a period of self-reflection for me and really an opportunity to hit the game running when some info materializes to analyze. You know?

[flash2015]

Go The Bunnies!!