webdiplomacy.net

Not that I know what would be appropriate, but I think that since this is Chippe’s first game and his first offense we should give him a single game ban.

DoubtingThomas wrote: ↑

Sat Aug 11, 2018 7:16 pm

and man this has to happen when i finally roled a non vanilla role, huh

Didn't you get veteran last game?

Yea I really feel bad for the GMs here. So much effort and of course I also wouldve preferred people just listened to me and lynched Jamie. My case was pretty good and it wasnt wrong.

If chipee hadnt influenced yalls opinions I think jamie wouldve still died from the validity of my arguments

I think we can perm ban chippee. Weve never perm banned someone, but no one, not even jamie has ever deadposted and ruined an entire game

We considered killing Jamie and giving the mafia an extra NK as a possible solution

Yea, I mean thats an option too. 1 shot Xtra kp is a fix on many sites

If the mafia players did not want the game to end, why was it stopped?

Damo was by far the deepest scum. Even with losing jamie, damo maybe wins

Gamora should be prevented from claiming their role. As serial killer I struggled about that. Maybe Soul Stone should be attached to a mafia.

bozotheclown wrote: ↑

Sat Aug 11, 2018 7:54 pm

If the mafia players did not want the game to end, why was it stopped?

The game was too compromised, too many calls for restarts. It was too broken to fix

It sounds like this could have been resolved with extra killing, not sure why we tried to keep an unfairly revealed player in the game.

The real winner is Xorxes, who got teleported out and didnt have to deal with any of this

@BB, to be fair you had half the players in the game listed as scum at some point

yavuzovic wrote: ↑

Sat Aug 11, 2018 7:55 pm

Gamora should be prevented from claiming their role. As serial killer I struggled about that. Maybe Soul Stone should be attached to a mafia.

Or perhaps Gamora shouldn't know they have a stone at all?

flash2015 wrote: ↑

Sat Aug 11, 2018 7:50 pm

DoubtingThomas wrote: ↑

Sat Aug 11, 2018 7:16 pm

and man this has to happen when i finally roled a non vanilla role, huh

Didn't you get veteran last game?

Yes. Yes I did. Uh but Veteran is kind of like a passive role, where I have to get targeted for me to do something. So maybe I should be saying an active PR? Idk. I got a similar role my only other time I rolled town PR, a hider, so that's why I exaggerated unconsciously, probably.

As it encourages a very early reveal

You know what, this was the best game I have played before ChippeRock ruined it. While I was voting for restart, I was begging to GMs for continuing.

WarLegend wrote: ↑

Sat Aug 11, 2018 7:57 pm

@BB, to be fair you had half the players in the game listed as scum at some point

I never had Jamie off my scum list.
Or HR

Never once townread eithrr

RagingIke297 wrote: ↑

Sat Aug 11, 2018 7:56 pm

bozotheclown wrote: ↑

Sat Aug 11, 2018 7:54 pm

If the mafia players did not want the game to end, why was it stopped?

The game was too compromised, too many calls for restarts. It was too broken to fix

I personally disagree, and I think the calls for a restart should have been ignored. I have made the same argument against ending diplomacy games were players start calling for the mods to cancel a game because of NMRs and CDs compromising the game.

The only thing chippee shouldve been annoyed with was the vig. I dont get why he was pissed at the rest of us. Most of us were townreading him and engaging him. His actions were unecessary, unwarranted, and they continued well after several warnings.

Id support a full, permanent ban from mafia and all mafia type games.