M60 - Duck Season? (Director's Cut) - Game Thread

[ghug]

Annoys me a little.

Why?

Because it is not super helpful.
But I think my annoyance may be due to the fact that my main water line has a leak that I just discovered.

Well that blows.

[Chaqa]

I just read through Rdr again and see no crumbs nor softing. So I dunno what scum saw. Would they bypass Chaqa for rando town just for his reads? Was it calling Durga’s defense of kgray a sorority thing?

Hey Chaq: you didn’t claim RBd.

Astute observation

For all that talk of townclears, you sure are leading the town.

I just got on my computer for the night

[BunnyGo]

I don't know, I'm not scum. There are tons of reasons and I'm not going to bother listing them because we all know them and it's just wifom.

I'm not saying I expected rivera to die. I'm saying I'm very suspicious that you were "shocked" by it.

https://www.adeevee.com/aimages/200206/ ... deevee.jpg

Are you trying to replicate the last game

Very clearly not. And last game I posted full episodes. You just didn’t watch them.

[ghug]

Astute observation

For all that talk of townclears, you sure are leading the town.

I just got on my computer for the night

It's ok, I don't actually want you to.

[Chaqa]

My vote is on Prado now.

I'm going to go back and review Day 1 tonight and tomorrow with the knowledge of summit's flip and the likelihood of Maniac being town. There's some real juicy VCA to be done.

[BunnyGo]

Is ghug going to be the only one to care that Bunny apparently went through the trouble of fake crumbing D1 to draw the night kill, and then seemingly outed himself as VT but making public his crumbs - which in turn would make him not draw the night kill after all??

I think ghugs post about Bunny potentially trying to get ahead of someone picking up on those fake crumbs is super plausible. Though the crumbs were obscure enough that I don’t know they were ever in danger of being found.

Yup. That‘s totally how scum win. Because webdip town are totally capable of finding them when they don’t screw around and shout HEY!!! IM SCUM! DID YOU KNOW I KNOW THE OTHER SCUM?!

No. Scum win here by sitting quietly and watching town implode. I’ve expressed this opinion before, and I stand by it now.

[Donny Dude]

Is ghug going to be the only one to care that Bunny apparently went through the trouble of fake crumbing D1 to draw the night kill, and then seemingly outed himself as VT but making public his crumbs - which in turn would make him not draw the night kill after all??

I think ghugs post about Bunny potentially trying to get ahead of someone picking up on those fake crumbs is super plausible. Though the crumbs were obscure enough that I don’t know they were ever in danger of being found.

Yeah, that does seem concerning.
I think I should look at bunny again because although I put him as town because of summit, he has dropped back to null again with some of his night posts.

[BunnyGo]

Bozo is seeing the light. I can get behind this.

##vote donny

[Tom Bombadil]

Is ghug going to be the only one to care that Bunny apparently went through the trouble of fake crumbing D1 to draw the night kill, and then seemingly outed himself as VT but making public his crumbs - which in turn would make him not draw the night kill after all??

I think ghugs post about Bunny potentially trying to get ahead of someone picking up on those fake crumbs is super plausible. Though the crumbs were obscure enough that I don’t know they were ever in danger of being found.

Yup. That‘s totally how scum win. Because webdip town are totally capable of finding them when they don’t screw around and shout HEY!!! IM SCUM! DID YOU KNOW I KNOW THE OTHER SCUM?!

No. Scum win here by sitting quietly and watching town implode. I’ve expressed this opinion before, and I stand by it now.

Then why did you bring up the crumbs?

[kgray]

Is ghug going to be the only one to care that Bunny apparently went through the trouble of fake crumbing D1 to draw the night kill, and then seemingly outed himself as VT but making public his crumbs - which in turn would make him not draw the night kill after all??

If Bunny was crumbing bugs and rivera just flipped bugs... how is Bunny still going to draw a NK with those crumbs?

I think ghugs post about Bunny potentially trying to get ahead of someone picking up on those fake crumbs is super plausible. Though the crumbs were obscure enough that I don’t know they were ever in danger of being found.

This part I buy, though, and I've already stated that I think the whole things is suspicious.

[Tom Bombadil]

He’s obviously not going to draw a night kill with those crumbs, but you only try to draw the NK as VT, so basically he is making it easier for scum to PR search by posting that - and I would think someone who supposedly tried to protect PRs would realize that.

[Tom Bombadil]

But maybe he’s just patting himself on the back for his clever fake crumbs and couldn’t contain himself.

[ghug]

Is ghug going to be the only one to care that Bunny apparently went through the trouble of fake crumbing D1 to draw the night kill, and then seemingly outed himself as VT but making public his crumbs - which in turn would make him not draw the night kill after all??

If Bunny was crumbing bugs and rivera just flipped bugs... how is Bunny still going to draw a NK with those crumbs?

I think ghugs post about Bunny potentially trying to get ahead of someone picking up on those fake crumbs is super plausible. Though the crumbs were obscure enough that I don’t know they were ever in danger of being found.

This part I buy, though, and I've already stated that I think the whole things is suspicious.

It's more that he spent a bunch of time laying really subtle hints to supposedly draw a nightkill, and then told us about it, which is a big fat signal to the mafia that he's a VT and not worth a nightkill.

[kgray]

Was thinking gerneally about potential busters of summit and I think kgray is pretty unlikely. She has shown she can definitely bus, but as someone who saw firsthand how summit struggled last time, I don’t think she would immediately throw him on the tracks this game.

I understand the angle of bussing the potential weak link, but I don’t know if kgray would be cold blooded enough to do that to someone she just played with as scum and saw struggle.

Yeah, so obviously people are free to believe this or not, but for the record after the game: there's no way I'd have been so harsh on summit if he were my teammate. I genuinely like him and I felt bad about my push even though I was convinced he was scum.

[Chaqa]

Is ghug going to be the only one to care that Bunny apparently went through the trouble of fake crumbing D1 to draw the night kill, and then seemingly outed himself as VT but making public his crumbs - which in turn would make him not draw the night kill after all??

If Bunny was crumbing bugs and rivera just flipped bugs... how is Bunny still going to draw a NK with those crumbs?

I think ghugs post about Bunny potentially trying to get ahead of someone picking up on those fake crumbs is super plausible. Though the crumbs were obscure enough that I don’t know they were ever in danger of being found.

This part I buy, though, and I've already stated that I think the whole things is suspicious.

It's more that he spent a bunch of time laying really subtle hints to supposedly draw a nightkill, and then told us about it, which is a big fat signal to the mafia that he's a VT and not worth a nightkill.

How do you know how the mafia interpreted it?

[kgray]

He’s obviously not going to draw a night kill with those crumbs, but you only try to draw the NK as VT, so basically he is making it easier for scum to PR search by posting that - and I would think someone who supposedly tried to protect PRs would realize that.

Okay but my point is, if he was crumbing bugs and bugs just got flipped - then he can't really be a PR for scum to mis-target anyway? What PR crumbs a different PR?

[ghug]

Was thinking gerneally about potential busters of summit and I think kgray is pretty unlikely. She has shown she can definitely bus, but as someone who saw firsthand how summit struggled last time, I don’t think she would immediately throw him on the tracks this game.

I understand the angle of bussing the potential weak link, but I don’t know if kgray would be cold blooded enough to do that to someone she just played with as scum and saw struggle.

Yeah, so obviously people are free to believe this or not, but for the record after the game: there's no way I'd have been so harsh on summit if he were my teammate. I genuinely like him and I felt bad about my push even though I was convinced he was scum.

When did webDip mafia get so wholesome?

[ghug]

He’s obviously not going to draw a night kill with those crumbs, but you only try to draw the NK as VT, so basically he is making it easier for scum to PR search by posting that - and I would think someone who supposedly tried to protect PRs would realize that.

Okay but my point is, if he was crumbing bugs and bugs just got flipped - then he can't really be a PR for scum to mis-target anyway? What PR crumbs a different PR?

You're ignoring the possibility that they didn't notice his crumbs and just thought he was another town player who could be a PR.

[ghug]

If Bunny was crumbing bugs and rivera just flipped bugs... how is Bunny still going to draw a NK with those crumbs?



This part I buy, though, and I've already stated that I think the whole things is suspicious.

It's more that he spent a bunch of time laying really subtle hints to supposedly draw a nightkill, and then told us about it, which is a big fat signal to the mafia that he's a VT and not worth a nightkill.

How do you know how the mafia interpreted it?

There are so many better things to humorously misinterpret and you choose this one?

[Tom Bombadil]

He’s obviously not going to draw a night kill with those crumbs, but you only try to draw the NK as VT, so basically he is making it easier for scum to PR search by posting that - and I would think someone who supposedly tried to protect PRs would realize that.

Okay but my point is, if he was crumbing bugs and bugs just got flipped - then he can't really be a PR for scum to mis-target anyway? What PR crumbs a different PR?

Yes - but what I’m saying is that scum likely would not have pieced together his crumbs if he hadn’t announced it to the world. The act of doing so slims PR pool. It’s either bad play as town or scum, and I think bunny with a town perspective would not have narrowed the potential PR pool like thag