M59 - Duck Season? - Game Thread

[BunnyGo]

Scum could get a gun?

Also that doesn't sound very fun for the protected townie tbh

Even with gun, is it to scum's wincon to shoot townie? Maybe...

Does 3P just play like the RR then? Make clear their townread and claim before we DK them?

Yeah I think scum always want to kill someone who isn't going to get daykilled, so they definitely want to shoot a confirmed town. The only reason I can think of not to is if there's also a confirmed PR.

That's probably what I'd do as that role. It's basically just a townie with extra info, but it's a little harder because if people notice you making unjustified townreads you might draw suspicion. Kind of like Macca did with HR lol

Ok. So 3P is just gambling on scum not getting a gun AND not having higher priority target.

Town get 2 townclears. One with no need of doctor or bomb.

[worcej]

2. All players are forbidden from posting screenshots or text contents of ANY game-related communications.

I apparently missed a shit show, but yes I also agree that bringing the actual words used from a role post is indeed against the rules.

You were the other GM from M46 where ChippeRock posting his entire role PM in the game thread, which you ruled was legal.

It was partly because of what you and Jamie said in M46 that made me believe what I was posting was not only legal but not against the spirit of the rules. I find it hard to believe you 2 are now claiming I broke a rule.

A slight difference, though it's meaningless, was Chippe technically just quoted the PM from the front page and not actually the post, thus that was my ruling.

I am not going to dig up exactly what you did, but if you were discussing the semantics of a post/GM communication, then that's against the rules IMHO. Regardless though, finding that different text for VT PMs were sent out is an unfortunately big screw up that led to a huge issue with the game. These things happen from time to time when you GM, so I have sympathy for all parties.

[rdrivera2005]

I think this is up to date:

1. Durga - YES
2. Vecna - YES
3. kgray - YES
4. Hellenic Riot - YES
5. worcej - YES
6. damo666 - YES
7. bozotheclown - YES
8. summit_fever - YES
9. Fluminator - YES
10. Chaqa - YES
11. BunnyGo - YES
12 - TrPrado - YES
13. rdrivera2005 -YES

14. seth24c
15. foodcoats
16. MoscowFleet
17. hthefourth
18. flash2015
19. yavuzovic
20. e.m.c^42
21.

[ghug]

I don't know what the fuck is going on but I can play if there's a new game and a spot open.

[BunnyGo]

I think this is up to date:

1. Durga - YES
2. Vecna - YES
3. kgray - YES
4. Hellenic Riot - YES
5. worcej - YES
6. damo666 - YES
7. bozotheclown - YES
8. summit_fever - YES
9. Fluminator - YES
10. Chaqa - YES
11. BunnyGo - YES
12 - TrPrado - YES
13. rdrivera2005 -YES
14. Ghug - YES

15. seth24c
16. foodcoats
17. MoscowFleet
18. hthefourth
19. flash2015
20. yavuzovic
21. e.m.c^42

[goldfinger0303]

Even with gun, is it to scum's wincon to shoot townie? Maybe...

Does 3P just play like the RR then? Make clear their townread and claim before we DK them?

Yeah I think scum always want to kill someone who isn't going to get daykilled, so they definitely want to shoot a confirmed town. The only reason I can think of not to is if there's also a confirmed PR.

That's probably what I'd do as that role. It's basically just a townie with extra info, but it's a little harder because if people notice you making unjustified townreads you might draw suspicion. Kind of like Macca did with HR lol

Ok. So 3P is just gambling on scum not getting a gun AND not having higher priority target.

Town get 2 townclears. One with no need of doctor or bomb.

In a massclaim there are easy higher priority targets. Cop/Jailor/Doc/Inventor should be 1/2/3/4 (in that order). And I think the cleared townies are excellent targets for the inventor

[BunnyGo]

Yeah I think scum always want to kill someone who isn't going to get daykilled, so they definitely want to shoot a confirmed town. The only reason I can think of not to is if there's also a confirmed PR.

That's probably what I'd do as that role. It's basically just a townie with extra info, but it's a little harder because if people notice you making unjustified townreads you might draw suspicion. Kind of like Macca did with HR lol

Ok. So 3P is just gambling on scum not getting a gun AND not having higher priority target.

Town get 2 townclears. One with no need of doctor or bomb.

In a massclaim there are easy higher priority targets. Cop/Jailor/Doc/Inventor should be 1/2/3/4 (in that order). And I think the cleared townies are excellent targets for the inventor

But 3P claiming is not needing the rest of the claim. It barely puts their known protectorate at risk. Only if scum get gun. It does help scum avoid the non-NK. But 3P doesn’t want them to even try.

[goldfinger0303]

Ok. So 3P is just gambling on scum not getting a gun AND not having higher priority target.

Town get 2 townclears. One with no need of doctor or bomb.

In a massclaim there are easy higher priority targets. Cop/Jailor/Doc/Inventor should be 1/2/3/4 (in that order). And I think the cleared townies are excellent targets for the inventor

But 3P claiming is not needing the rest of the claim. It barely puts their known protectorate at risk. Only if scum get gun. It does help scum avoid the non-NK. But 3P doesn’t want them to even try.

Ah, I see what you're getting at. Fair point.

[MoscowFleet]

This is up to date:

1. Durga - YES
2. Vecna - YES
3. kgray - YES
4. Hellenic Riot - YES
5. worcej - YES
6. damo666 - YES
7. bozotheclown - YES
8. summit_fever - YES
9. Fluminator - YES
10. Chaqa - YES
11. BunnyGo - YES
12 - TrPrado - YES
13. rdrivera2005 -YES
14. Ghug - YES
15. MoscowFleet - YES

15. seth24c
16. foodcoats
18. hthefourth
19. flash2015
20. yavuzovic
21. e.m.c^42

[MoscowFleet]

Also, sorry to my teammates for that horrible day 1. I guess I could complain about Flum bussing me, but honestly I played so poor that it was probably a good play.

[MoscowFleet]

But hey, on the bright side, we didn't lose!!

[Jamiet99uk]

Current re-confirmed player list:
1. Durga - YES
2. Vecna - YES
3. kgray - YES
4. Hellenic Riot - YES
5. worcej - YES
6. damo666 - YES
7. bozotheclown - YES
8. summit_fever - YES
9. Fluminator - YES
10. Chaqa - YES
11. BunnyGo - YES
12 - TrPrado - YES
13. rdrivera2005 -YES
14. Ghug - YES
15. MoscowFleet - YES
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
21.

People who have not yet confirmed if they wish to be in the re-start:
seth24c
foodcoats
hthefourth
flash2015
yavuzovic
e.m.c^42

If you are not on either list and wish to join, add your name to the open slots.

[Tom Bombadil]

I can play if you need help filling game - just won’t be quite as active as normal.

[seth24c]

I can also play if needed. I will be absent for periods but I will do my best to keep up.

[yavuzovic]

I'm unable to play. I'm sorry for the absence in the cancelled game

[flash2015]

I will play if needed to make the numbers...but I can't promise I won't go full worcej again...

[Jamiet99uk]

Current re-confirmed player list:
1. Durga - YES
2. Vecna - YES
3. kgray - YES
4. Hellenic Riot - YES
5. worcej - YES
6. damo666 - YES
7. bozotheclown - YES
8. summit_fever - YES
9. Fluminator - YES
10. Chaqa - YES
11. BunnyGo - YES
12 - TrPrado - YES
13. rdrivera2005 -YES
14. Ghug - YES
15. MoscowFleet - YES
16. Flash2015 - can play
17. Tom Bombadil - can play
18. Seth24c - can play
19.
20.
21.

People who have not yet confirmed if they wish to be in the re-start:
foodcoats
hthefourth
e.m.c^42

If you are not on either list and wish to join, add your name to the open slots.

[bo_sox48]

Corrected.

Current re-confirmed player list:
1. Durga - YES
2. Vecna - YES
3. kgray - YES
4. Hellenic Riot - YES
5. worcej - YES
6. damo666 - YES
7. bozotheclown - YES
8. summit_fever - YES
9. Fluminator - YES
10. Chaqa - YES
11. BunnyGo - YES
12 - TrPrado - YES
13. rdrivera2005 -YES
14. Ghug - YES
15. MoscowFleet - YES
16. Flash2015 - can play
17. Tom Bombadil - can play
18. Seth24c - can play
19.
20.
21.

Subs
1. emc

People who have not yet confirmed if they wish to be in the re-start:
foodcoats
hthefourth

If you are not on either list and wish to join, add your name to the open slots.

[worcej]

I will play if needed to make the numbers...but I can't promise I won't go full worcej again...

What is this supposed to mean?!

[flash2015]

I will play if needed to make the numbers...but I can't promise I won't go full worcej again...

What is this supposed to mean?!

self-voting :)