MAFIA 49 -Avengers "Re-release"- GAME THREAD [HIDDEN]

[yuuki]

I like Jamie's personality choice this game so far. he's been soft and fun. did something good happen in your life recently? :D

in terms of content not as sure, but

Probably means he is scum?

If he is scum it will become more apparent in future days as his reads/cases will turn out...slightly anal retentive and inane. I'm just happy for him in general this game lmao, he seems less pissed at everything in the world

Are they not inane as town though? I wonder if M48 was just an off game for him or if it is common

[Jamiet99uk]

Probably means he is scum?

If he is scum it will become more apparent in future days as his reads/cases will turn out...slightly anal retentive and inane. I'm just happy for him in general this game lmao, he seems less pissed at everything in the world

Are they not inane as town though? I wonder if M48 was just an off game for him or if it is common

My pronouns are "He / His".

[e.m.c^42]

Is Maniac a maniac though? Because if he is then maybe he just makes no sense

He's a smart player.

Why are people scumreading Maniac? I have him as a solid town read, I don't think scum Maniac would push Xorxes the way he did.

I would not mind joining a Chaqa wagon as I want to call his bluff.

I think Maniac may be deliberately obfuscating his posts. Somewhat agree with your point, Chaqa pulled the same bluff before in Neph's game successfully with me lol

[KalelChase]

I like Jamie's personality choice this game so far. he's been soft and fun. did something good happen in your life recently? :D

in terms of content not as sure, but

Well, last week I got laid for the first time in over a year, so, maybe it's down to that.

Congratulations.

[yuuki]

Then you wanting people to consolidate on Chaqa/ND, when you're missing half of the story, is weird.

So if you find gold in a corner of a river it is 'weird' that you have not checked the entire river for gold? Is it less gold?

I'm not quite unbiased, but this post seems really dismissive and forced.

I'm still catching up, it is true that my reads may change. There may have been a massive clue that would make me change my mind. But I'm just saying I doubt it because I already found gold. It is not often that gold turns out to be pyrite, but not unheard of.

[yuuki]

If he is scum it will become more apparent in future days as his reads/cases will turn out...slightly anal retentive and inane. I'm just happy for him in general this game lmao, he seems less pissed at everything in the world

Are they not inane as town though? I wonder if M48 was just an off game for him or if it is common

My pronouns are "He / His".

Hiss

[xorxes]

Why are people scumreading Maniac? I have him as a solid town read, I don't think scum Maniac would push Xorxes the way he did.

You think his case on me made actual sense, it came from a genuine town perspective, he really believed in what he was saying? And the way he reacted to being called out for his lazy vote for BG was towny?

[Chaqa]

Oh no, rivera has seen through my ruse of offering myself up to be lynched. Whatever shall I do. /s

It's Day 1. Going back to the first fucking mafia game on this site, I have made a routine habit of playing terribly. Hell, I was the first person ever lynched in webdip mafia.

If you want me to be helpful, you have to either lynch me Day 1 or accept that my skillset and attention come later on.

[brainbomb]

Is Maniac a maniac though? Because if he is then maybe he just makes no sense

He's a smart player.

Is brainbomb a smart player?

https://thenypost.files.wordpress.com/2 ... 410&crop=1

[e.m.c^42]

Probably means he is scum?

If he is scum it will become more apparent in future days as his reads/cases will turn out...slightly anal retentive and inane. I'm just happy for him in general this game lmao, he seems less pissed at everything in the world

Are they not inane as town though? I wonder if M48 was just an off game for him or if it is common

There's only a bit out there but understandable, and then there's inane detail nitpicking, for lack of other things to easily build cases on. But then again, this is coming from me, others may have different opinion.

[Vaporwave]

Chaqa is very much town this game, yes a bit uninspiring, but full-fledged town

If Maniac gets to be killed by a meteorite and flips scum, remember this resistance to his wagon

so far, there are only 2 sexy towns on him: me and xorxes

people have come up with excuses for him, to be noted for later

[yuuki]

Worcej: In light of my comments, I want you to persuade me that your "Who would you NK?" thing was town motivated.

Get this right, Woecej, if you're town, or there will be consequences.

There is never consequences with you.

The point was to reaction test you ding dong, here are the results:

1. I would kill bozo for his solving skills.
2. EMC would kill whoever looked like a PR.
3. Damo would kill xorxes unless he was on his team.
4. Maniac would kill a PR and wondered if I've ever played.
5. Kistune would kill brain.
6. Xorxes brought up the logic of food dying last game, but did not indicate who he would kill now.

The other 16 did not respond to the question. Some reacted to it though:

1. Jamie freaked out like he normally does. Usually it's because some lied about something, this time it was my question.
2. Darg didn't like me doing something and stating I was doing it without explaining it.
3. Bunny wasn't against my question and saw some sort of value out of it. Responded to Jamie's wall of freakout.
4. Food also responded saw the reaction test and did comment he initially thought it was weird.
5. EP also saw the reaction test and thought Jamie was over the top and could spin my question any way towards PR fishing.

That drops the list of people who didn't engage with it to the following:

1. yuuki - who is MIA from the game
2. Brain - who is surprisingly quiet atm
3. Neph - no real comment atm
4. Vapor - I still find him weird and the same old vapor...
5. bozo - focusing on his list and generating his own responses
6. rdr - Doing his own thing, usually ignores me anyways
7. Fox - Also ignores me, unless he scums me and goes all-in tunneling
8. Temasek - No impression
9. Kalel - New, not much of an impression atm
10. Chaqa - ever the lurker atm

My theory is some of the scum would dodge this question intentionally. My guess is at least 2/4 are probably inside the 10 in the above list. Striking yuuki out, that leaves 9 people to look at for a D1 vote.

I believe that should be enough for you Jamie, point your 'threat' at someone else.

Just found this and I have to say I think this reaction test was a horrible idea. I can see mafia using it to guide a couple of NKs and blame a townie for them.

[Jamiet99uk]

Worcej: In light of my comments, I want you to persuade me that your "Who would you NK?" thing was town motivated.

Get this right, Woecej, if you're town, or there will be consequences.

There is never consequences with you.

The point was to reaction test you ding dong, here are the results:
<snip>
I believe that should be enough for you Jamie, point your 'threat' at someone else.

Just found this and I have to say I think this reaction test was a horrible idea. I can see mafia using it to guide a couple of NKs and blame a townie for them.

I'm glad someone agrees with me about this!

[xorxes]

I read the Chaqa-ND mutual voting again and I don't really see the bussing.

I guess it's possible, but town-town, town-scum or scum-town are all just as likely or more likley. What's the mutual bussing telltale?

[yuuki]

There is never consequences with you.

The point was to reaction test you ding dong, here are the results:
<snip>
I believe that should be enough for you Jamie, point your 'threat' at someone else.

Just found this and I have to say I think this reaction test was a horrible idea. I can see mafia using it to guide a couple of NKs and blame a townie for them.

I'm glad someone agrees with me about this!

I also find it curious that ND is not on that list

[bozotheclown]

I'm going to go with foodcoats, Chaqa, ND, and kalel as scum team. I really have no real read on kalel as scum yet though so that is to be taken with a massive grain of salt.

From everything I see, I think we should try to consolidate on Chaqa and ND wagon as the likelihood of one of them being scum is really high

scum survey:
bozo: Vapor, emc, rdrivera, Nephthys
BunnyGo: emc, Kalel, bozo, brainbomb
Nephthys: Espresso, Jamie, foodcoats, bozo
Vapor: darg, Espresso, Temasek, ?
Espresso: Foxcastle, emc, Kalel, xorxes
damo: Chaqa, darg, emc, Kalel
foodcoats: brainbomb, emc, Foxcastle, Maniac
darg: Vapor, BunnyG, Kitsune, emc
Maniac: xorxes, Espresso, Kalel, ?
Kitsune: bozo, Temasek, ?, ?
rdrivera: Espresso, bozo, Kalel, Foxcastle
Temasek: Kalel, Espresso, xorxes, bozo
worcej: rdrivera, Kalel, darg, emc
brainbomb: rdrivera, Chaqa, ND, ?
Chaqa: Vapor, ?, ?, ?
emc:
Foxcastle: Espresso, ?, ?, ?
Jamie: bozo, worcej, ND, ?
Kalel: Espresso, ?, ?, ?
ND: Chaqa, ?, ?, ?
xorxes: Espresso, ?, ?, ?
yuuki: foodcoats, Chaqa, ND, Kalel

Preliminary results:
Espresso 8
Kalel 8
emc 7
bozo 6
Chaqa 4
darg 3
Foxcastle 3
rdrivera 3
Vapor 3
xorxes 3
brainbomb 2
foodcoats 2
ND 3
Temasek 2
BunnyGo 1
Jamie 1
Kitsune 1
Maniac 1
Nephthys 1
worcej 1

[bozotheclown]

Somehow Foxcastle has more votes than scum reads of him.

[yuuki]

I read the Chaqa-ND mutual voting again and I don't really see the bussing.

I guess it's possible, but town-town, town-scum or scum-town are all just as likely or more likley. What's the mutual bussing telltale?

Well duh it's freaking D1. We are all grasping at straws here. On D1 being slightly more likely to be scum than a random pick is good enough for me. I'm not saying this is a lock. I'm just saying it is a scummy interaction meaning maybe we have a 10% higher chance of catching scum

##Vote ND

I'm liking this pressure and want to see if there is any reaction

[rdrivera2005]

Why are people scumreading Maniac? I have him as a solid town read, I don't think scum Maniac would push Xorxes the way he did.

You think his case on me made actual sense, it came from a genuine town perspective, he really believed in what he was saying? And the way he reacted to being called out for his lazy vote for BG was towny?

I think the case on you came from a town perspective as I had the same feeling. I didn't remember the vote on BG and had to look on the bot. It's a weak reasoning maybe but I fail to see it as scummy.

[bozotheclown]

##VOTE emc

Of my scum reads, emc is the most widely suspected, but had no votes.