Mafia 46 - Ace Attorney - GAME THREAD

[connorcompton]

@Connor: what's your theory on why Damo had a RB claim the same night you did?

@Foxcastle
@Percy

Here's what I think:

Up to that point (and kind of still now?) I had been quite absent from the game. I think since I am new, and absent, scum thought that I would for some reason not claim roleblock, or not notice damo's claim for so long that I wouldn't be trusted. Because of that they decided to risk a fairly unimportant Mafia member on that in the hopes he would be trusted.

I don't see many other possibilities that make sense.

Why do you think scum didn't target you before? Shouldn't this have been a strategy from Day 2?

You mean try to paint me as scum D2 so when damo makes the claim people are more likely to trust him? I guess that would make sense. The reason they didn't could be down to poor day co-ordination, laziness, or confidence in their plan.

To be honest, I don't know what the Mafia thinks, because I'm not.

[Foxcastle]

Okay, just went back and started skimming D1 and wow. Flavius looks even worse than I remember.

[Percy Williams]

@Connor: what's your theory on why Damo had a RB claim the same night you did?

1. Scum coordination
Damo and Connor are both Scum, creating a Town clear for the remaining player.

2. Scum Miscoordination
Damo and Connor are both scum. Scum team held the Roleblock, and accidentally had two claimants, plausible since Connor is very lurky this game.

3. Scum Damo recovering from Town RB.
This suggests the mafia team wants to discredit the accidental townclears RB's make. This was an attempt that clearly backfired though.

[Percy Williams]

I think It's between Connor an Fox, and I'm really thinking 1 or 2 is more likely.

[Percy Williams]

I think It's between Connor an Fox, and I'm really thinking 1 or 2 is more likely.

[Percy Williams]

Ignore the double post.

[Foxcastle]

I worry that if the game slips into Saturday, it will be a pathetic anti-climax. I won't be around on Saturday for EOD. I will be on Friday and plan on working on the game through then.

I encourage you all to PM the GMs to end the night phase at the regular deadline time today.

[Foxcastle]

COME ON PEOPLE! WAKE UP! DO SOMETHING

[Foxcastle]

Does it still count for the longest Mafia game ever if

[Foxcastle]

Does it still count for the longest Mafia game ever if

I

[Foxcastle]

Does it still count for the longest Mafia game ever if

I

Do

[Foxcastle]

Does it still count for the longest Mafia game ever if

I

Do

Shit

[Foxcastle]

I

Do

Shit

Like

[Foxcastle]

Do

Shit

Like

This?

[Foxcastle]

I mean, given how much of any other mafia thread is spam, I assume it must...

[Foxcastle]

I have PM'd my request to end this phase at the regular deadline time today. Please join me so that we can get on to the finale.

Otherwise, game will effectively end on Friday afternoon (unless there's an endhammer, but honestly, there really shouldn't be for the final day). And then we will just sit around until the GMs process it on Saturday and nobody will be paying attention.

Whether you're scum or town, you should want an audience for your moment of glory/defeat.

[Foxcastle]

I think It's between Connor an Fox, and I'm really thinking 1 or 2 is more likely.

Can you explain more? I really think you need to go back and look at D1 on Flavius. He was clearly saved by scum (particularly Damo with an early vote to boost Bozo's wagon).

Are you scumreading Flavius at all? or just scumreading me and Connor more?

[yavuzovic]

Foxcastle is being bold. After Squigs' death he starts to scumread me, when he was townreading me. I neither know why Squigs townread me nor why Foxcastle scumread me, but what I know is Squigs was right and Fox is (intentionally or unintentionally) shading town me. I can't say he is scum for this but waiting for Squigs's death is a bit fishy in my opinion. I'm not going to defend myself - I can't even if I try, how will I know what Flavius intended to do, without talking to him.
I now have something like a list among you three:

Percy Williams
I don't have an arguement against him. I don't think anyone has. We know there is only one scum left and I truly agree with Percy about it to be between Fox and connor. In this case I can say Percy is clearer than you.

connorcompton
Dangerous to ignore, but my case about him to be worried when I removed my vote from et to see his reaction, he was confused.

So Squigs has pitted me against Fox... I liked your vote analysis, it was almost comforting. I think Fox is probably scum, but I'm not willing to discard the chances of Percy though.

Seeing Squigs die after this post is making me worried about him too. Scum!connor might think using Squigs' vote analysis against Fox. In this case he could have killed Squigs to make Fox even more suspect.

Foxcastle
My top suspect is Foxcastle, he is very likely to be mafia for the points Squigs pointed out. Seeing Squigs die after that is making this case stronger but I am not sure scum!foxcastle would kill Squigs in this way especially when he was scumreading Fox. Maybe double bluff?

[connorcompton]

Scum!connor might think using Squigs' vote analysis against Fox. In this case he could have killed Squigs to make Fox even more suspect.

Foxcastle
My top suspect is Foxcastle, he is very likely to be mafia for the points Squigs pointed out.

Hmm...

[Foxcastle]

Right, so Percy is just AWOL.

Are either of you planning to endhammer this phase?