Mafia 46 - Ace Attorney - GAME THREAD

[teacon7]

@et ... you want to see my "reading" ? Do you mean you want a list of reads from me?

[et]

@et ... you want to see my "reading" ? Do you mean you want a list of reads from me?

That need not to be list.
I want to know your thought.

[peterlund]

Again, Balki isnt a scum, but he sure as heck isnt BA

What kind of flawed logic is this? Balki claimed BA and by this accepted the rdrivera's reporter scan to be accurate. Meaning Balki is a PR that was out. Only BA and scum PRs remains that can be "out"...

[peterlund]

That judge can get us a lynch of Mafia tomorrow. He's not useless.

Only if the Judge is able to select 2 scum he is useful, but why do you think the Judge will be able to? He/she may instead select 2 town/BA for the vote. Quite useless role imo.

[FlaviusAetius]

Flav wants us to ignore my entire scum pool Nice.

Yup

His "lynch pool" includes pretty much all of my townreads.

Already explained; Nephthys started talking the others haven't, I said Day 3 isnt a good thing to kill lurkers, and we should lynch the active people first, if you think thats a bad idea then say so, cause right now all your saying is all the people who have been talking arent scum and that makes no sense

[FlaviusAetius]

##vote flav

He isn't at all staying up to date. Purely reactive play and not solving.

Then there's the car bomb...

Ok listen, here's how I play;
I leave the tab open of the bot and this
and I have a third tab of my webdiplomacy games
Then I go back from the page I am at and respond to all the comments I can
and then after I respond I see the front page and make comments on that or say my own stuff
Now this could mean I am responding to things without sometimes over 20-30 pages of context
Also today is my Highschool graduation so sorry, not sorry if Im not up to date

[FlaviusAetius]

##vote Balki

No, we aren't killing Balki today. I don't think we can correctly lynch mafia six times in a row. I'd rather have Balki scanning / trying to kill mafia for us to give us better odds.

He's scum, so let the BA kill him, no need to waste our lynch on him
With the people, the BA has killed it literally makes no sense for it to be Balki
Those people weren't even close to being scum
but they also weren't suspecting Balki
I think the BA was self-preserving and that doesnt fit in with Balki

[Durga]

##vote Balki

No, we aren't killing Balki today. I don't think we can correctly lynch mafia six times in a row. I'd rather have Balki scanning / trying to kill mafia for us to give us better odds.

He's scum, so let the BA kill him, no need to waste our lynch on him
With the people, the BA has killed it literally makes no sense for it to be Balki
Those people weren't even close to being scum
but they also weren't suspecting Balki
I think the BA was self-preserving and that doesnt fit in with Balki

The only person killed by the BA was trprado

[FlaviusAetius]

That's about it Nephthys, also imo
I think we should ignore lurkers, for now, there are too many at this point and I feel like we are taking a shot in the dark if we go after them, lets instead focus on active players where we got information and can find things out
If we get the active players we can then go for the lurkers
The current lurkers are
Xorxes
Percy
Connor
teacon
peterlund
damo

Their probably scum there, but honestly its not even worth going after them at this point, so lets go after someone else

We also can ignore Balki since the BA will take care of him
We can also ignore et since the two picks were likely town v town
We can also ignore rdrivera, I still think him revealing Balki so soon is silly but what you going to do

Flavius(me)
FoxCastle(scum)
Squigs
ND
Nephthys
Durga
Chippie

I think in this pot there's a few scum

@Flav
Do you think how many scums in 'Lurkers' ?
If 5 scums lurking, we are going to lose.
And am I more towny than Durga?
If you think so, please tell me why.

I think its probably an even split, if not most of the scum are lurkers
I just think its a shot in the dark if we go after them today, instead lets make them talk today and tonight and the next day, so we get enough information from them
Lets lynch with the info we know

[FlaviusAetius]

TrPrado died EoN2 - HE WAS Dick Gumshoe, THE TOWN COP. BA killed
Tom Bombadil died EoN2 - He was ??? of ???. Mafia killed

EspressoPatronum died EoD2 - HE WAS THE WEAK OLD MAN, THE VANILLA TOWNIE! Lynched

CruaaderReynauld died Day 2 - He was a random spectator, the VANILLA TOWN.

dargorygel died Day 2 - He was Mike Meekins, the TOWN BAILIFF. Mafia/BA killed
Carl Tuckerson died Day 2 - He was Ema Skye, the VANILLA TOWN. Mafia/BA killed

bozotheclown died EoD1 - He was CROAD McLAUGHLIN, a Vanilla Town! Lynched

[Durga]

Isn't it narrowing the lynch pool why don't you try to make some lurkers participate? If we all vote for a lurker they have to defend themselves

[FlaviusAetius]

No, we aren't killing Balki today. I don't think we can correctly lynch mafia six times in a row. I'd rather have Balki scanning / trying to kill mafia for us to give us better odds.

He's scum, so let the BA kill him, no need to waste our lynch on him
With the people, the BA has killed it literally makes no sense for it to be Balki
Those people weren't even close to being scum
but they also weren't suspecting Balki
I think the BA was self-preserving and that doesnt fit in with Balki

The only person killed by the BA was trprado

False two people were killed by BA how else do 2 people die in one night??

[Durga]

TrPrado died EoN2 - HE WAS Dick Gumshoe, THE TOWN COP. BA killed
Tom Bombadil died EoN2 - He was ??? of ???. Mafia killed

EspressoPatronum died EoD2 - HE WAS THE WEAK OLD MAN, THE VANILLA TOWNIE! Lynched

CruaaderReynauld died Day 2 - He was a random spectator, the VANILLA TOWN.

dargorygel died Day 2 - He was Mike Meekins, the TOWN BAILIFF. Mafia/BA killed
Carl Tuckerson died Day 2 - He was Ema Skye, the VANILLA TOWN. Mafia/BA killed

bozotheclown died EoD1 - He was CROAD McLAUGHLIN, a Vanilla Town! Lynched

The BA is not responsible for every kill in the game. Why did you post this

[FlaviusAetius]

Isn't it narrowing the lynch pool why don't you try to make some lurkers participate? If we all vote for a lurker they have to defend themselves

Ok which lurker do you propose, and will people be on to switch, I dont want a bozo 2.0

[Durga]

He's scum, so let the BA kill him, no need to waste our lynch on him
With the people, the BA has killed it literally makes no sense for it to be Balki
Those people weren't even close to being scum
but they also weren't suspecting Balki
I think the BA was self-preserving and that doesnt fit in with Balki

The only person killed by the BA was trprado

False two people were killed by BA how else do 2 people die in one night??

Two people were killed my the mafia assassin. Not the blind assassin

[FlaviusAetius]

TrPrado died EoN2 - HE WAS Dick Gumshoe, THE TOWN COP. BA killed
Tom Bombadil died EoN2 - He was ??? of ???. Mafia killed

EspressoPatronum died EoD2 - HE WAS THE WEAK OLD MAN, THE VANILLA TOWNIE! Lynched

CruaaderReynauld died Day 2 - He was a random spectator, the VANILLA TOWN.

dargorygel died Day 2 - He was Mike Meekins, the TOWN BAILIFF. Mafia/BA killed
Carl Tuckerson died Day 2 - He was Ema Skye, the VANILLA TOWN. Mafia/BA killed

bozotheclown died EoD1 - He was CROAD McLAUGHLIN, a Vanilla Town! Lynched

The BA is not responsible for every kill in the game. Why did you post this

Read the comment below it

[Durga]

And read my next comment

[FlaviusAetius]

And read my next comment

Assassin: “You are Shelly de Killer, the MAFIA ASSASSIN. Each day you must vote for a suspect. At night you can talk to the other Mafia in the Mafia QT at <...>. Your teammates are <...>. Because you are a world class assassin, you will be the instrument of death for the Mafia team. During the night phase, you will perform the night kill by targeting a player. This player will die at the end of the night phase. While you are alive in the game you will always carry out the night kill, unless the Bailiff jails you before you can execute it! Additionally, being a master of disguise, you have a one-shot day kill that you enact by PM’ing the GMs (Jamiet99uk and worcej) a command of ‘##KILL <player>’ via PM or the Mafia QT. Once a GM processes the command, the kill will happen immediately during the day phase. You win when all of the town have been eliminated, or nothing can stop this from happening.”

It was the BA I just reread

[Durga]

And read my next comment

Assassin: “You are Shelly de Killer, the MAFIA ASSASSIN. Each day you must vote for a suspect. At night you can talk to the other Mafia in the Mafia QT at <...>. Your teammates are <...>. Because you are a world class assassin, you will be the instrument of death for the Mafia team. During the night phase, you will perform the night kill by targeting a player. This player will die at the end of the night phase. While you are alive in the game you will always carry out the night kill, unless the Bailiff jails you before you can execute it! Additionally, being a master of disguise, you have a one-shot day kill that you enact by PM’ing the GMs (Jamiet99uk and worcej) a command of ‘##KILL <player>’ via PM or the Mafia QT. Once a GM processes the command, the kill will happen immediately during the day phase. You win when all of the town have been eliminated, or nothing can stop this from happening.”

It was the BA I just reread

That's not the BA that's the mafia assassin

[Durga]

It literally says: the MAFIA assassin

Read the rest of the set up please