Mafia 46 - Ace Attorney - GAME THREAD

[FlaviusAetius]

underline means strike idk how to strike

[ND]

Question who even made connor a suspect against damo thats Nepthys level pairing

They both claimed rb d4 so someone is lying

[FlaviusAetius]

Question who even made connor a suspect against damo thats Nepthys level pairing

They both claimed rb d4 so someone is lying

I would venture to guess damo, Tom, Chippie, Carl and Connor are my towncore ever since they didnt settle on the easy wagon that was me or bozo so far Ive been right

[FlaviusAetius]

Ok back to catching up

[connorcompton]

I can't let this good list go to waste, so we'll just see if someone counterclaims.

1. Chippe
2. connor (no)
3. et
4. Flavius (no)
5. Foxcastle
6. ND
7. Percy (yes)
8. Squigs
(8. damo)

[connorcompton]

I can't really see much of a scenario where Chippe pretends to be very adamant on BA killing me or damo, and getting into a ridiculous argument over whether the less likely scum should be killed first, to then be the BA and kill peter instead.

If ND were BA, I'd imagine he'd kill et, since he thinks he's scum, and nobody else is paying much attention so it would be the only chance he'd have.

I think Chippe BA is much less likely now, still could be ND, I'm thinking Flavius though.

[connorcompton]

I can't really see much of a scenario where Chippe pretends to be very adamant on BA killing me or damo, and getting into a ridiculous argument over whether the less likely scum should be killed first, to then be the BA and kill peter instead.

If ND were BA, I'd imagine he'd kill et, since he thinks he's scum, and nobody else is paying much attention so it would be the only chance he'd have.

I think Chippe BA is much less likely now, still could be ND, I'm thinking Flavius though.

Hang on, the WIFOM is killing me, a BA Chippe killing peter would be an excellent deception tactic.

[Percy Williams]

Also, I took a break earlier from the game, so Im more calm now, Im not really sorry for being like that though since I think it was warranted and Im not taking anything back, and I still think FoxCastle is scum every known towns person thinks hes scum ie; Carl, TrPrado, rdrivera, Espresso
Tom said he's coming around on him since his Day 1, but still wasnt sure
Darg never really said anything about him
Bozo never really said anything about him

If we look at everyone who Fox has voted for;
On Day 1
Me almost 7 hours before EoD he was even on near EoD(i think even 8 mintues before EoD) and said he would change if convinced, and never was to change to TrPrado

He votes MoscowFleet despite being obvious lurker(why is he going lurker on Day 2)?
He also now goes TrPrado on Day 2, great timing

And he stays on Espresso the entire day

That's mighty biased on Fox's end mr. Percy, scum partner?

Yours is mighty biased against him! Get out of your tunnel, and discuss the logic on how he has to be scum here at the tea table, without repeating that everyone town died scum reading him. Either way I don't think my is biased towards him, and anyone is allowed to scum read him, but it only helps scum to repeat incorrect facts. I strongly dislike emphatic generalizations used as proof.

[ND]

Yeah could still be Chippie, considering Peter was a secondary BA read for me it means I need to also re-evaluate who could also fit into that position.

[Squigs44]

Wtf just happened?

Why did they kill Neph over Durga?
Why did BA kill Peter?
Why is Flav completely disregarding the fact that damo and Connor both claimed RB yesterday?

Is one of damo/Connor BA?

[Squigs44]

There are only three reasons BA would have killed Peter instead of damo/Connor.

1) Either damo or Connor is BA. They knew if they killed the other, they would be the lynch today.
2) The BA thought one of damo/Connor was mafia but not both, and was unsure which it was. They were more certain of Peter mafia than either damo or Connor
3) The BA is an idiot

[Squigs44]

Durga you know what you being alive means, don't you?

[connorcompton]

me and damo possibilities:

1. We're both Mafia, so neither are BA.

2. One is Mafia, the other was roleblocked town.
In that case, no, not BA.

3. One is roleblocked town, the other is fake rb-claiming BA.
Then the Mafia would know who BA is, and roleblock them. Not Possible

3. One is mafia, the other is fake rb-claiming BA.
Then the Mafia would know who BA is, and roleblock them. Not Possible.

[connorcompton]

There are only three reasons BA would have killed Peter instead of damo/Connor.

1) Either damo or Connor is BA. They knew if they killed the other, they would be the lynch today.
2) The BA thought one of damo/Connor was mafia but not both, and was unsure which it was. They were more certain of Peter mafia than either damo or Connor
3) The BA is an idiot

So only 2 and 3 are possible. or:

4) Mafia are idiots.

[Durga]

Durga you know what you being alive means, don't you?

I feel like it's really scummy that you're even saying this. It's totally wifom

[Durga]

It's possible that BA tracked peterlund N1 and once I claimed IC they knew he was scum.

[Squigs44]

me and damo possibilities:

1. We're both Mafia, so neither are BA.

2. One is Mafia, the other was roleblocked town.
In that case, no, not BA.

3. One is roleblocked town, the other is fake rb-claiming BA.
Then the Mafia would know who BA is, and roleblock them. Not Possible

3. One is mafia, the other is fake rb-claiming BA.
Then the Mafia would know who BA is, and roleblock them. Not Possible.

Not necessarily. Mafia could have held their RB on a town/BA scenario to try to have the BA kill town then get lynched. This is unlikely, but so are the other scenarios.

[Squigs44]

Durga you know what you being alive means, don't you?

I feel like it's really scummy that you're even saying this. It's totally wifom

It means they think you're a liability to town

[Percy Williams]

I find it unlikely that Damo or Connor are Ba. The Ba's Rincon is to be alive in the last three players. This means the Ba needs Things to be in balance, as they need the Town to need them, and need to make sure the Mafia don't win too quickly. Especially with all the Town players starting to hunt for Ba, the Ba has no reason to kill in Damo/Connor. Not doing so 1.occupies us as we decide which one to kill or both. 2. If combined with a Town kill, makes us need the BA, as us figuring it out means the Mafia know and can roadblock him, but if we need him to be able to kill Mafia to win, we won't root him out. I believe HE was killing someone they thought was town, but not choosing an actual Townclear, as they knew scum would lynch from that pile.

[Durga]

Durga you know what you being alive means, don't you?

I feel like it's really scummy that you're even saying this. It's totally wifom

It means they think you're a liability to town

Oh? Does it? Are you in their scum qt and have they told you that?