Mafia 46 - Ace Attorney - GAME THREAD

[ChippeRock]

@peter: what do you make of moscow's play? Were you surprised to find out your alignment?

@teacon, as I recall peter already answered your question (at least the 2nd one). It's very surprising you don't know this...

I still haven't read the part where peter subbed in. It's likely he talked about it there? I've got like ~70 pages of reading to catch up on.

Hold on, you're making reads and voting and you haven't read 70 of the most recent pages?!?

[teacon7]

foxcastle, xorx, squigs, and 2-3 of the 4 "nulls" from above. Neph is a special case that I don't know how to handle, but he's on the team when I put together a scumteam in my head, he's on it. .

Who do you think TrP scanned on N1?

idfk.
I think TrP scanned foxcastle. fwiw, my case on you isn't built on a half-crumbed TrP scan. If I find something on reread (If I get a chance) I'll let you know.

[teacon7]

@teacon, as I recall peter already answered your question (at least the 2nd one). It's very surprising you don't know this...

I still haven't read the part where peter subbed in. It's likely he talked about it there? I've got like ~70 pages of reading to catch up on.

Hold on, you're making reads and voting and you haven't read 70 of the most recent pages?!?

no chippe, I missed n1-n2, and am skimming while we go.

[teacon7]

heck, I even put a disclaimer about that at the top of my reads.

[Jamiet99uk]

VOTE COUNT 3.3

xorxes (6) - Foxcastle, Squigs44, Durga, Balki Bartokomous, Percy Williams, Nephthys
Foxcastle (3) - FlaviusAetius, ChippeRock, teacon7
FlaviusAetius (1) - damo666
connorcompton (1) - et
ChippeRock (1) - peterlund
Percy Williams (1) - xorxes

Unvoted: rdrivera2005, ND

Currently XORXES is set to be lynched.

20 hours and 12 minutes are left in Day 3.

Connorcompton still needs to meet the voting and posting requirements.

[Nephthys]

VOTE COUNT 3.3

xorxes (6) - Foxcastle, Squigs44, Durga, Balki Bartokomous, Percy Williams, Nephthys
Foxcastle (3) - FlaviusAetius, ChippeRock, teacon7
FlaviusAetius (1) - damo666
connorcompton (1) - et
ChippeRock (1) - peterlund
Percy Williams (1) - xorxes

Unvoted: rdrivera2005, ND

Currently XORXES is set to be lynched.

20 hours and 12 minutes are left in Day 3.

Connorcompton still needs to meet the voting and posting requirements.

I'm gonna laugh so hard if connor is town, doesn't post and gets modkilled.

[Foxcastle]

foxcastle, xorx, squigs, and 2-3 of the 4 "nulls" from above. Neph is a special case that I don't know how to handle, but he's on the team when I put together a scumteam in my head, he's on it. .

Who do you think TrP scanned on N1?

idfk.
I think TrP scanned foxcastle. fwiw, my case on you isn't built on a half-crumbed TrP scan. If I find something on reread (If I get a chance) I'll let you know.

What is your case on me built on?

[ChippeRock]

foxcastle, xorx, squigs, and 2-3 of the 4 "nulls" from above. Neph is a special case that I don't know how to handle, but he's on the team when I put together a scumteam in my head, he's on it. .

Who do you think TrP scanned on N1?

idfk.
I think TrP scanned foxcastle. fwiw, my case on you isn't built on a half-crumbed TrP scan. If I find something on reread (If I get a chance) I'll let you know.

I agree with you here. My vote on Foxcastle doesn't have anything to do with TrPrado's possible crumbed scan of Fox (I personally think the argument he's crumbing for Squigs is more convincing).

[Foxcastle]

Who do you think TrP scanned on N1?

idfk.
I think TrP scanned foxcastle. fwiw, my case on you isn't built on a half-crumbed TrP scan. If I find something on reread (If I get a chance) I'll let you know.

What is your case on me built on?

Also, if you're town, and since you're under pressure, do you believe it's more important to make one really good case on who you think is scum, or to try to make as many reads and smaller cases as possible in that situation?

[ChippeRock]

VOTE COUNT 3.3

xorxes (6) - Foxcastle, Squigs44, Durga, Balki Bartokomous, Percy Williams, Nephthys
Foxcastle (3) - FlaviusAetius, ChippeRock, teacon7
FlaviusAetius (1) - damo666
connorcompton (1) - et
ChippeRock (1) - peterlund
Percy Williams (1) - xorxes

Unvoted: rdrivera2005, ND

Currently XORXES is set to be lynched.

20 hours and 12 minutes are left in Day 3.

Connorcompton still needs to meet the voting and posting requirements.

I'm gonna laugh so hard if connor is town, doesn't post and gets modkilled.

If he did, it would solidify this game as a failure.

[Jamiet99uk]

##CALL GM Can the Blind Assassin be roleblocked by the Mafia's Hooker?

GM NOTE: Yes. The Blind Assassin is not immune from being Roleblocked.

[rdrivera2005]

ND: Probably town.

Hard hitting question alert!...

Why?

I don't have a solid read on ND, but considering his pushes and the way he is missing lately, I have him in my current scumteam and my ISO list for tomorrow.

[rdrivera2005]

Those posts by damo are not townie. They are in fact really worthless and don't contribute to anything.

Second one in my scumteam.

[Percy Williams]

Fine.
This is only distracting from the important scum hunting, so I will fully explain.

First the Jailer conversation. Upon seeing Carl's "Jailer slip" I wanted to make sure a scum wasn't leaving a crumb of something to call back on, so I wanted to force Carl to solidify what it meant. Upon his responses, I realized that he might be the Jailer and actually slipped, which would have been terrible if I brought the Mafia to the actual Jailer, so my solution to discredit the entire discussion was to jokingly fakeclaim jailer myself. From then on I read him as town.

The next thing, the super secret Pr role I was trying to cloud: Judge.
I noticed that a lot of people were complaining about the judges choices, and that foolishly, I had done the same. I suspected that the judge had not complained about their own choices, and to prevent the Mafia team from coming to the same conclusion and having a very limited pool of remaining judge possibles to NK from, I insinuated that I would have complained about my choice, and that any other judge would as well, trying to throw the Mafia off the trail. I honestly thought there were two unclaimed town Prs left: Innocent Child and judge, so I didn't want to explain my thoughts on who might actually be the judge. Regardless I wouldn't have shared until all our Prs were dead ( like I said) as nothing is certain until the flip by GM, or the game was over, but my hand has been forced. I really hope I don't lose us the game at the jonbar hinge again.

The throw away line with Chippe and innocent child was 1/3 to cover for accidentally saying it had to do with innocent child, 1/3 a legitimate possibility, and 1/3 trying to further confuse who the innocent child was.


I'm not saying I did it right, but that's what I did and why.

And If any one has called me out of revealed anything since Squigs saying

Xorxes I made a short post about Percy's play, with the conclusion that Percy is not the best lynch today. Convince me I'm wrong.

I didn't see it. I left the computer on and did other things.

[damo666]

Been out drinking. About 20pp behind. Any drama?

[Balki Bartokomous]

Been out drinking. About 20pp behind. Any drama?

The game ended. Blind Assassin won. Can you please post a link to the Scum QT so we can all read it?

[Nephthys]

Fine.
This is only distracting from the important scum hunting, so I will fully explain.

First the Jailer conversation. Upon seeing Carl's "Jailer slip" I wanted to make sure a scum wasn't leaving a crumb of something to call back on, so I wanted to force Carl to solidify what it meant. Upon his responses, I realized that he might be the Jailer and actually slipped, which would have been terrible if I brought the Mafia to the actual Jailer, so my solution to discredit the entire discussion was to jokingly fakeclaim jailer myself. From then on I read him as town.

The next thing, the super secret Pr role I was trying to cloud: Judge.
I noticed that a lot of people were complaining about the judges choices, and that foolishly, I had done the same. I suspected that the judge had not complained about their own choices, and to prevent the Mafia team from coming to the same conclusion and having a very limited pool of remaining judge possibles to NK from, I insinuated that I would have complained about my choice, and that any other judge would as well, trying to throw the Mafia off the trail. I honestly thought there were two unclaimed town Prs left: Innocent Child and judge, so I didn't want to explain my thoughts on who might actually be the judge. Regardless I wouldn't have shared until all our Prs were dead ( like I said) as nothing is certain until the flip by GM, or the game was over, but my hand has been forced. I really hope I don't lose us the game at the jonbar hinge again.

The throw away line with Chippe and innocent child was 1/3 to cover for accidentally saying it had to do with innocent child, 1/3 a legitimate possibility, and 1/3 trying to further confuse who the innocent child was.


I'm not saying I did it right, but that's what I did and why.

And If any one has called me out of revealed anything since Squigs saying

Xorxes I made a short post about Percy's play, with the conclusion that Percy is not the best lynch today. Convince me I'm wrong.

I didn't see it. I left the computer on and did other things.

Or you just wanted to seed fake claims for yourself.

Also, you said that you were trying to protect the inno. There is no point in doing so when he is hidden. Therefore you reaaaallly should have said this earlier. If you're town I'm deeply disappointed.

[rdrivera2005]

I think it's true that Xorxes doesn't bus. I was looking at some of his recent games (he's rolled scum a lot lately), and I think that's true. But it's also a useless factoid this game with him on Percy on D1 and with the judge on D2. He is usually on one of the lead wagons.

He just won a game with him and Jamiet bussing each other so hard that he get to lylo when Brain decided to throw the game. So you two are both lying. More two for the team. Two to go.

[ND]

Eh I'm not missing. I just don't have a ton of time during the day and only really have the nights. Plus, I've been spending a lot of time looking back at the thread. Sorry that I work guys. I'll quit my job so I can play forum mafia with everyone.

[Foxcastle]

I think it's true that Xorxes doesn't bus. I was looking at some of his recent games (he's rolled scum a lot lately), and I think that's true. But it's also a useless factoid this game with him on Percy on D1 and with the judge on D2. He is usually on one of the lead wagons.

He just won a game with him and Jamiet bussing each other so hard that he get to lylo when Brain decided to throw the game. So you two are both lying. More two for the team. Two to go.

Which? My samples are M42, M44, and M45, but only Days 1-2.