Mafia 46 - Ace Attorney - GAME THREAD

[Durga]

@percy please respond to my question.

I suppose a xorx lynch works but know that when he flips Percy is pretty much conf scum.

@Durga, who's your current Poe?

Scum team: xorx - teacon - damo - connor

then i'm torn. fox is looking more and more likely. maybe ND is being nice to me bc he's scum. i think if there's a deep scum it's Chippe. I don't have a good read or any read on peterlund so he's also an option.

[Balki Bartokomous]

Scum team:

Xorxes, Flavius, Damo, ND, teacon, and maybe et?

I think that holds up.

[Nephthys]

@percy please respond to my question.

I suppose a xorx lynch works but know that when he flips Percy is pretty much conf scum.

@Durga, who's your current Poe?

Scum team: xorx - teacon - damo - connor

then i'm torn. fox is looking more and more likely. maybe ND is being nice to me bc he's scum. i think if there's a deep scum it's Chippe. I don't have a good read or any read on peterlund so he's also an option.

So you towbread flav?

[Balki Bartokomous]

Oooo, interesting cross-post.

[Nephthys]

I disagree with you two over damo. He is usually more engaged as scum.

Look through my ISO to where I shift town on him. His thinking just prior to that is so pure you can follow it easily. You can't fake that.

[Balki Bartokomous]

I am feeling more and more certain about Damo too. His participation pattern fits scum I remember him a lot more at the center of participation in the one game I played with Town!Damo.

[Nephthys]

Also @durga @balki

What do you make of the weak case xorx made on Percy. I don't see how that can't be busssing

[Balki Bartokomous]

I disagree with you two over damo. He is usually more engaged as scum.

Look through my ISO to where I shift town on him. His thinking just prior to that is so pure you can follow it easily. You can't fake that.

Part of it is that we're just running out of people. There are six effing scum out there.

[xorxes]

Map of situation:

rdrivera2005: Reporter (almost 100% certain)
Nephthys: Judge (pretty certain, dies tomorrow if not)
Balki Bartokomous: BA (seems most likely scenario, scan confirmed by Neph)
Durga: Likely Town. Claimed jailed with Bailiff dead.
Squigs44: Likely town. Roleblock + potential inno cop scan.

ChippeRock: Towny. Hard to see D1 shennanigans as scum ploy.
et: Towny. Participating and trying to solve with reasonable arguments.
FlaviusAetius: "Too scummy to be scum". Could be scum but likely town.
ND: Probably town.

That leaves, roughly from scummy to scummiest:

Foxcastle: Potential guilty cop scan, but stayed home N1. There was something that made me think not likely scum with Percy.
damo666: Some participation here and there, but nothing that stands out.
connorcompton: I have to raread. No impression whatsoever.
peterlund: Nothing from Moscow, very little from peter.
teacon7: Active day one, left with preplanned excused, hasn't done anything since. (I still have to read last couple of pages.)
Percy Williams: The only one I have felt true scum vibes from, my strongest read. ##VOTE Percy

[Balki Bartokomous]

Also @durga @balki

What do you make of the weak case xorx made on Percy. I don't see how that can't be busssing

Well, I mean, his whole game has been weak.

I am just looking at it from a perspective of camaraderie. I could see Xorxes bussing a teammate. But not just doing it all day long and into the next day, especially with a newer teammate (I'm assuming Percy is pretty new, is that right?). It does not fit, to me.

[Percy Williams]

I'm only on page 105 in my catch up so far, but I promised questions:
1. Did Trprado's analysis on you and the accompanying questions make sense? or were there a lot of false assumptions in it?
2.Who all is using new reading methods? If you are, please share if it doesn't ruin the method.
3. Has anyone been posting full reads lists (Besides TrPrado)? I feel like we should do that...

This is trying to fit in 101. Any townperson would read the last 15 pages before contributing. Things can change quickly and to do things just because theyve been promised...

Any Townsperson with TIME would. I was unexpectedly busy for the past couple days.Also as a Town, I don't want to make promises I don't keep as that makes me suspicious looking, and a Town gets lynched. I also wanted these questions to restructure the way we're looking at the game, to try and make some headway.

I just find it too ironic that Percy responds to Tom's very sensible admonition against PR hunting with ideas for PR hunting.

@Foxcastle, I know it looks like I'm publicly Pr hunting but I'm not. I would explain what I'm doing to actually confuse the Scum team, but that would obviously ruin it, and give scum a lot of helpful information. After the game I'd be happy to explain myself( Or if all Prs die).

@Percy, theres only one left now. Wanna share?

It's about one of the town Prs left, sooo no.

[Balki Bartokomous]

Speak of the Devil and he shall appear.

[xorxes]

@Fox, @Squigs, @Durga: If you have questions for me, please ask now. I won't be here for EOD and the ~18 hours leading to it, so we better get it out of the way soon.

[Durga]

Nice to see xorx has neither evolved, nor managed to convince us of lynching his ONE scum read.

because yes, i totally buy that town xorx has one scum read that he hasn't immensely tunnelled and pushed.

that being said

@neph damo got caught IMMEDIATELY as scum last game. i'm willing to bet he's decided lurking is a better option for him

[Nephthys]

Map of situation:

rdrivera2005: Reporter (almost 100% certain)
Nephthys: Judge (pretty certain, dies tomorrow if not)
Balki Bartokomous: BA (seems most likely scenario, scan confirmed by Neph)
Durga: Likely Town. Claimed jailed with Bailiff dead.
Squigs44: Likely town. Roleblock + potential inno cop scan.

ChippeRock: Towny. Hard to see D1 shennanigans as scum ploy.
et: Towny. Participating and trying to solve with reasonable arguments.
FlaviusAetius: "Too scummy to be scum". Could be scum but likely town.
ND: Probably town.

That leaves, roughly from scummy to scummiest:

Foxcastle: Potential guilty cop scan, but stayed home N1. There was something that made me think not likely scum with Percy.
damo666: Some participation here and there, but nothing that stands out.
connorcompton: I have to raread. No impression whatsoever.
peterlund: Nothing from Moscow, very little from peter.
teacon7: Active day one, left with preplanned excused, hasn't done anything since. (I still have to read last couple of pages.)
Percy Williams: The only one I have felt true scum vibes from, my strongest read. ##VOTE Percy

Give me your logic on Percy. Give me a wall. Make your entire case please

[Durga]

@Fox, @Squigs, @Durga: If you have questions for me, please ask now. I won't be here for EOD and the ~18 hours leading to it, so we better get it out of the way soon.

i don't really have questions for you. you're not really playing and you're not leading town and you're not pushing your scum read. what more is there?

[Nephthys]

Nice to see xorx has neither evolved, nor managed to convince us of lynching his ONE scum read.

because yes, i totally buy that town xorx has one scum read that he hasn't immensely tunnelled and pushed.

that being said

@neph damo got caught IMMEDIATELY as scum last game. i'm willing to bet he's decided lurking is a better option for him

Fair, I still want your interpretation of when I shifted him to town.

[Durga]

Nice to see xorx has neither evolved, nor managed to convince us of lynching his ONE scum read.

because yes, i totally buy that town xorx has one scum read that he hasn't immensely tunnelled and pushed.

that being said

@neph damo got caught IMMEDIATELY as scum last game. i'm willing to bet he's decided lurking is a better option for him

Fair, I still want your interpretation of when I shifted him to town.

i don't understand what you're asking of me

[Percy Williams]

@percy please respond to my question.

I suppose a xorx lynch works but know that when he flips Percy is pretty much conf scum.

@Durga, who's your current Poe?

Which Question if I haven't responded to it already. I read from the back to the present, so where ever I Quote is where I am.

[Balki Bartokomous]

ND: Probably town.

Hard hitting question alert!...

Why?