MINI MAFIA V GAME THREAD -- The House of Black and White

[Percy Williams]

This is where you assume Moscow is town.

Yes, he's suggesting that Jamie might be scum trying to kill town. If he's right, MF is likely town.

But he wasn't, so..

Yeah, because Jamie was town, that post and my analysis tells us nothing, because Jamiet didn't know who town and scum were.
If Jamiet had been Mafia, then Moscow would have been town.

To answer Squiggs initial inquiry, now that he has finally made himself clear, I didn't know whether or not Moscow was town, but I didn't want us to lynch anyone without any information, so that we didn't get distracted from hunting the scum.

[Percy Williams]

I do have to ask though Percy, why did you just now decide to bring this up? You posted several times after I made that initial post, yet you didn't respond to it once.

Which post are you calling the "initial post"?

[Ryast]

Hey, I’m here. Looks like I’m a wagon today. I’ll look back for the reasons.

[Ryast]

Right, looks like it’s pressure stuff

My bad for not really doing much. I’m not used to this few posts, and also the lack of avatars is making this surprisingly difficult to keep track of

Not really sure where I want to be

[dargorygel]

@emc... you asked about my ping on squiggles... it comes down to this,for me. It's Day 1 (or duplicate Day 1...) we don't have any PR's and the resulting mechanics.... we don't yet have much voting analysis. Day 1 overconfidence always concerns me. I have found that in general, Day 1 overconfidence comes from one of two things... poor reasoning, or scum.

Squigs seems overconfident, to me.

Percy has shown up, and I accept (fwiw) his explanation.

So I am back to:
##VOTE SQUIGS

[Claesar]

I think you're very happy for someone who just killed a townie.

[Squigs44]

I do have to ask though Percy, why did you just now decide to bring this up? You posted several times after I made that initial post, yet you didn't respond to it once.

Which post are you calling the "initial post"?

The one where I said you scum slipped. That purpose of that post was to see what your (or others) reactions were to it. That's why I originally didn't say what it was. My line of questioning afterwards built on it though.

[brainbomb]

OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT 2.0
Squiggs (3) Percywilliams, RagingIke, Dargorygel
Ryast (2) Vaporwave, Squiggs
EMC (1) Claesar

Not Voting: (4) Ezio, Moscowfleet, Ryast, EMC

3 hours and 43 minutes remain

[Squigs44]

@emc... you asked about my ping on squiggles... it comes down to this,for me. It's Day 1 (or duplicate Day 1...) we don't have any PR's and the resulting mechanics.... we don't yet have much voting analysis. Day 1 overconfidence always concerns me. I have found that in general, Day 1 overconfidence comes from one of two things... poor reasoning, or scum.

Squigs seems overconfident, to me.

Percy has shown up, and I accept (fwiw) his explanation.

So I am back to:
##VOTE SQUIGS

I feel like I'm pretty confident in my town reads of Ike, Moscow, and Vapor. My scum reads really don't have much confidence though. The fact that I have switched between Jamie, you, Percy, and Ryast as my top scum read this game should show that.

Why am I confident in my townreads?
Ike I'm confident because we had the exact same reactions for the first two hours of the game. That shows me that he has the same perspective as me. Vapor I'm townreading based on his read of Percy mostly. Also his tone this game has resonated well with me. Moscow is town for a number of reasons. He's pretty darn obvious as scum in the few posts he does make as scum, but here he has been both active and solid.

[Squigs44]

Claesar is thinking logically and open-minded. I mostly like it, but he is a bit too cautious. Definitely not a lynch option right now.

[Squigs44]

Ezio has flown under my radar by doing very little. His opening gives me a slight town lean, but I want to see more.

[Squigs44]

Lol I'm going to get lynched because I gave the person I voted for a template to make an idea into an actual argument.

[Ezio]

##vote Ryast

[Claesar]

Lol I'm going to get lynched because I gave the person I voted for a template to make an idea into an actual argument.

No, you're getting lynched because clueless townies are voting with scum.

[Claesar]

Emc has been posting a lot of fluff, but doesn't vote until minutes before the deadline. Does Emc usually play like that? My vote is still going there.

FINAL DAY 1 VOTE COUNT
Jamiet99uk (3) dargorygel, Ryast, emc

I'd prefer to lynch from this group. If there's no change in half an hour, I guess I'll join the most likely wagon on any of these three.

[brainbomb]

OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT 2.1
Squiggs (3) Percywilliams, RagingIke, Dargorygel
Ryast (3) Vaporwave, Squiggs, Ezio
EMC (1) Claesar

Not Voting: (3) Moscowfleet, Ryast, EMC

2 hours and 45 minutes remain

[MoscowFleet]

Not a fan of the Squigs wagon, definitely not this early. He's been the most helpful player so far, let scum take care of him.

I'm gonna stick with ##Vote EMC. Not particularly opposed to any lynch besides Squigs and Ryast who I'm leaning town, and Claesar and Vapour, who I want to see more from.

[Claesar]

Time to go for me.
##unvote
##vote Ryast

Did I need to add the unvote? I presume not.

If I'm the NK, my dying wish is to lynch Emc. Don't be fooled by people telling you scum lynched me because I said this, so you will kill townie Emc. My wish still stands, because I don't believe he's town. I'll admit I don't have a very strong read and will update if I live through the night.

If you think this post makes me look scummy, the only thing I can offer is that I didn't vote for Jamie even though he voted for me. That's because I was scumhunting rather than trying to save my own hide.

What is dead may never die.

[Claesar]

Not a fan of the Squigs wagon, definitely not this early. He's been the most helpful player so far, let scum take care of him.

I'm gonna stick with ##Vote EMC. Not particularly opposed to any lynch besides Squigs and Ryast who I'm leaning town, and Claesar and Vapour, who I want to see more from.

I appreciate that you're voting with me, but I can't keep my vote on Emc since I'm logging off and will miss EOD.

[Vaporwave]

Not faulting you Ryast, most people have done nothing but tickle each other toes.

Sadly, I'm more like an assistant instead of a leader so I'm not sure where to start