Mafia 42 - Space Ghost Coast to Coast - OFFICIAL GAME THREAD

[Nephthys]

Brainbomb is actually correct that CrimsonFox is defending Ghug a whole lot.

Possible Crimson ML setup when ghug flips scum? (Ghug had 2 votes Cri had 3 at that stage)

[thamrick]

Brainbomb is actually correct that CrimsonFox is defending Ghug a whole lot.

Possible Crimson ML setup when ghug flips scum? (Ghug had 2 votes Cri had 3 at that stage)

But why? I don't think he'd really need to work that hard to set up Crimson as a ML based on how widely scumread he was at that point.

Seems more likely that he was trying to shade the leading wagons to keep the momentum going. To me, points to t/t

[Nephthys]

@Xorxes: Could you explain why ThdFrance is your current top scumread? I'm not clear on why you are voting for him.

Unsure if Jamie here would do this to a scum Xorx. Especially as he really doesn't like Xorx's response.

Town points for xorx

[thamrick]

Ezio is NEVER scum with moscow unless fleet is godfather

Ezio
Day-1 01:34
page 67 / orig
↑MoscowFleet: "Why you got such a boner for me, Tom? You asked me some fair questions and I answered them, but all you responded with i..."

Moscow stop being wrong about verifiable things. Tom has made posts about other people, and has used good reasoning. You just think he's only focused in you because you're only paying attention to what references you.
That's a shit way to play the game as town

This is the kind of post that I think brainbomb gets his jollies off of posting as scum. I guarantee that there's a post somewhere where bb spells out the scumteam.

[Nephthys]

What the fuck is going on here?

I'm going to go to sleep and hope that when I wake up, all of you have died.

Well that would have increased the win streak

[Nephthys]

I am going to review the low posters as I'm on my phone, it's possible, and they tend to go unnoticed.


Peterlund

Peterlund has posted three times.

His first post is a complaint that Durga is not in the game. Aw.

His second post provides a list of hedgy reads on about half a dozen people, and a vote for CF because CF is "arrogant" and "has something to hide"...

Well that's a great reason for a vote. Oh, no, it isn't.

His third post repeats how he thinks CF is "hiding something" (by directly quoting his previous post).

That's it. Peter's entire contribution.

SCUMLEAN

Apparently low posters are purely thd and peter (the only two he did). I don't recall the post count at the time but darg finished with 7 posts (again unsure of how long he had) and bozo had 10.

I think therefore that one of thd/peter is likely scum.

Scum points for peter

[Nephthys]

Do you really think a scum emc would post something like that?

Why do you feel the need to respond on his behalf?

Are we only allowed to ask people questions if we scumread them? Is that a new rule?

I think here Jamie was trying to "catch" emc out.

Town points for emc

[Nephthys]

I just spent 20 minutes typing a long post examining all the stated reasons of ND voters. Then lost phone signal and the post was lost. I'm pissed off.

The summary of my thoughts is that I think ThdFrance was saved, and Elmo looks scummy. I will post this again in detail when I get home.

No reasoning for logic, unsure if he's telling the truth but more towniness onto emc

[Nephthys]

##VOTE CRIMSONFOX

Attacking people and calling them scum because they want proper participation instead of unsupported votes and shitposting, at this stage in the game, is dogshit.

CrimsonFox has done nothing all game but shitpost, shitpost, shitpost. He clogs up the thread with dozens of meaningless, content-free memebro posts that add nothing to the discussion, do not help town learn anything, and demonstrate no attempt at hunting or questioning.

When people ask sensible questions or try to scumhunt, Crimson attacks them or shitposts in huge volume in an apparent attempt to make any serious play become lost in a swamp of nonsense.

He is the noisy scum, running distraction for his team. I retract my suspicion that ThdFrance was saved. This guy would have been the correct D1 wagon. Let's lynch him now.

Looks like Jamie trying to set up a lynch based on something that would have resonated with many town

[Nephthys]

I like that new MU idea:

n1 green check RHK

##vote Jamie btw for being rude towards the MUers, the new fresh blood over here!

That was exactly the same reason you gave for voting ND.

Are you just going to vote for people because you think they're rude?

For the second day in a row you are voting someone for a reason that does not involve you scumreading them.

This is highly suspect.

Jamie keeps mentioning peter. Admittedly peter had just posted but I cant stop seeing him coming up...

[Nephthys]

6. DoubtingThomas - Slight town. He's all over the place but most of the time I get the impression he's trying to solve.

7. e.m.c^42 - Town. He's new here so no meta but pretty much all of his activities scream "new townie". His list of 'styles' looks like the genuine efforts of a player who doesn't know anyone else's meta, trying not only to read alignment but also to read playstyle and equip himself with a three dimensional picture of the players. I'd be very surprised if a newbie scum would go to that effort or that level of detail.

8. Ezio - Null. Ezio didn't do much in D2. His D1 was also fairly low volume. Nothing he did or said screamed scum to me but I don't remember him obvtowning either.

9. flash2015 - Dead town. RIP.

10. Dargorygel (was Food) - Slight scum. Really hasn't given us much since subbing in. A couple of things I did notice, w

11. ghug - Town. He looks and feels like a town Ghug. He's reacted with impatience to people making useless noise and doing Things We Don't Do Here, but that's how I'd expect Ghug to behave. I think Brainbomb's case on him is fabricated. It's weird that Vecna and Brainbomb are acting almost in unison on this one since I town-read Vecna, but there we go.

12. Jamiet99uk - Town, duh.

The ghug case looks pretty forced, a meta read after 153 pages?

[thamrick]

I'm out of time. If you guys do end up lynching me

Town:
Tom
darg
bozo
LQ
Neph

Less sure, but still town:
Vecna
CF
peter
rdr
ghug
Ezio
Vapor

Unsure:
Ike
damo
DT
emc
RHK

Scum:
xorxes
MoscowFleet

Basically in order of who I find scummiest to least scummy.

##VOTE MoscowFleet

[Nephthys]

Ezio is NEVER scum with moscow unless fleet is godfather

Ezio
Day-1 01:34
page 67 / orig
↑MoscowFleet: "Why you got such a boner for me, Tom? You asked me some fair questions and I answered them, but all you responded with i..."

Moscow stop being wrong about verifiable things. Tom has made posts about other people, and has used good reasoning. You just think he's only focused in you because you're only paying attention to what references you.
That's a shit way to play the game as town

This is the kind of post that I think brainbomb gets his jollies off of posting as scum. I guarantee that there's a post somewhere where bb spells out the scumteam.

I could see brain doing this, regardless though, im not sure he did.

[Nephthys]

I'm gonna drop a ##vote ghug for now. I wanna see some discussion of this.

[Ezio]

I'm gonna drop a ##vote ghug for now. I wanna see some discussion of this.

This is insane.

[CrimsonFox]

i can't decide who to shoot

[CrimsonFox]

i was roleblocked

When?

never

[Nephthys]

I'm gonna drop a ##vote ghug for now. I wanna see some discussion of this.

This is insane.

I was townreading him until I reread jamie. Now I'm not so sure, just trying to get some discussion going

[bozotheclown]

I'm gonna drop a ##vote ghug for now. I wanna see some discussion of this.

This is insane.

Why, because he claims he was RBed?

[Vecna]

Ok, let's make this interesting ##vote thdfrance

This vote by rivera looks horrible.

Vote count was:

thd (6)
Jamiet (5)
bozo (5)

and rivera made it:

thd (7)
Jamiet (5)
bozo (4)

Ironically this actually makes me townread him. If bozo is scum, scum rivera keeps bussing him every time. If bozo is town, scum rivera doesn't try to save Jamie, I don't think.

thats a pretty good point actually