https://webdiplomacy.net/contrib/phpBB3/
https://webdiplomacy.net/contrib/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?f=4&t=1110
It's good to know you will consider changing your mind if I get NKed, we were all wondering about that.bozotheclown wrote: ↑Sat Dec 08, 2018 6:00 pmI was hoping we could get a consensus on xorxes today. Unless xorxes get NKed, I do not see anything changing my mind D5.
That doesn't answer the question though. In order for bussing to be involved you had to assume that I was scum. How does 5 people voting for me indicate that I'm scum? Because unless I'm mistaken this is where your case against me started: you assumed that I was scum and then proceeded from there.bozotheclown wrote: ↑Sat Dec 08, 2018 5:21 pm5 different players voted for you at some time on D1, but one hour before EOD you had no votes. It seemed like it could be an indicator that 1 or 2 scum were voting for you at some point during the day before moving their vote.
OK, that's a fair point.bozotheclown wrote: ↑Sat Dec 08, 2018 5:29 pmThis is not true, my case was not based just on Jamie not answering my questions, it was based on the things I was questioning him for in the first place. The fact that he seemed to be evading my questions was the reason I voted for him over my other scum reads. I think it is pretty obvious for anyone who just reread my posts that I was already suspecting Jamie, so this conclusion from xorxes reinforces my suspicion of him.xorxes wrote: ↑Sat Dec 08, 2018 4:56 pmD2: Opening post:
I think nobody else was scumreading Jamiet at the time, and his whole case was that he had failed to address his questions, which is about as unconvincing a case you can make on someone.bozotheclown wrote: ↑Sat Dec 01, 2018 1:34 amxorxes has somewhat alleviated my suspicion of him for now, and brainbomb seems more town like, so my preferred lynch pool is down to Jamie, thdfrance, and worcej.
Here are my complete reads:
town lean: DrCJG, foodcoats, Nephthys
neutral: xorxes, brainbomb
scum lean: Jamie, thdfrance, worcej
My first choice is Jamie, since he has failed to address a number of my questions.
##VOTE Jamiet99uk
How do you think town xorxes would have reacted? DrCJG voted for me for not showing interest in your hypo-proposal. Can't get scummier than that.bozotheclown wrote: ↑Sat Dec 08, 2018 5:54 pm
Here are some examples of things I would "not expect from town xorxes":
1. Your reaction to DrCJG after he voted for you.
What would you have expected town xorxes to do?2. Your following brainbomb onto RagingIke D1.
OK, fair enough. You scumread him for that and I didn't, at least not strongly enough to make a point about it. I thought it was consistent with Jamiet's behavior that day which seemed like town Jamiet to me. Obviously you were right and I was wrong. I think Jamiet started moving down my list sometime around that point, but I don't remember exactly when.3. Your town read of Jamie after D1.
Why do you think that's more likely from scum xorxes than from town xorxes?4. Your END vote on Jamie immediately after worcej's claim D2.
Don't you think town xorxes would reevaluate his reads after knowing worcej and Jamiet's alignment?4. The unexplained change of your Nephthys read from one of your strongest town reads to one of your top two scum reads N2.
You two were my top suspects, it may be that as I became more convinced about DrCJG I became less convinced about you, but I don't see why you would think that's scummy in any way.5. The apparent change in your read of me after I started pushing DrCJG D3.
but scum!Jamie also doesnt want to end up voting on Damo if both neph and tdh are scumAn easier explanation is that he didn't want to end voting next to Nephthys (or even worse Nephthys and thd). Why jump to my wagon and not to Ike's?
But how did they know Nephthys would be shot? Do you think they decided who would do the kill in the last three minutes?rdrivera2005 wrote: ↑Wed Dec 05, 2018 12:11 amThey didn't. Obviously they have Nephthys doing the nightkill, so the other scum don't have any risk of being tracked.
Not sure what you're asking, sorry. Aren't we saying the same thing?brainbomb wrote: ↑Sat Dec 08, 2018 11:56 pmIm reading your case on Jamie and I noticed you asking why Jamie wasnt on damo and you said:
but scum!Jamie also doesnt want to end up voting on Damo if both neph and tdh are scumAn easier explanation is that he didn't want to end voting next to Nephthys (or even worse Nephthys and thd). Why jump to my wagon and not to Ike's?
ah. yes. we are actuallyxorxes wrote: ↑Sun Dec 09, 2018 12:04 amNot sure what you're asking, sorry. Aren't we saying the same thing?brainbomb wrote: ↑Sat Dec 08, 2018 11:56 pmIm reading your case on Jamie and I noticed you asking why Jamie wasnt on damo and you said:
but scum!Jamie also doesnt want to end up voting on Damo if both neph and tdh are scumAn easier explanation is that he didn't want to end voting next to Nephthys (or even worse Nephthys and thd). Why jump to my wagon and not to Ike's?
Is sarcasm scum indicative for you?xorxes wrote: ↑Sat Dec 08, 2018 9:52 pmIt's good to know you will consider changing your mind if I get NKed, we were all wondering about that.bozotheclown wrote: ↑Sat Dec 08, 2018 6:00 pmI was hoping we could get a consensus on xorxes today. Unless xorxes get NKed, I do not see anything changing my mind D5.
My suspicion of you started with your reaction to DrCJG's vote, and continued with your town read of Jamie after D1. The fact that so many people voted for you then changed their vote is what made it seem like it could be bussing, as I would expect scum bussing you to be more likely to move their vote later than a town who actually suspected you as scum. I agree this a weak argument against you, so it is not surprising that you are trying to present it as more significant than it was. I do not think I referred back to this again, except when you have brought it up.xorxes wrote: ↑Sat Dec 08, 2018 10:04 pmThat doesn't answer the question though. In order for bussing to be involved you had to assume that I was scum. How does 5 people voting for me indicate that I'm scum? Because unless I'm mistaken this is where your case against me started: you assumed that I was scum and then proceeded from there.bozotheclown wrote: ↑Sat Dec 08, 2018 5:21 pm5 different players voted for you at some time on D1, but one hour before EOD you had no votes. It seemed like it could be an indicator that 1 or 2 scum were voting for you at some point during the day before moving their vote.
If your suspicion started somewhere else please point to where, because this is where I'm tracking it down to.
Before I was pushing DrCJG I think you thought you needed to lynch me as one of your two mislynches, but after I started pushing DrCJG, I think you saw the opportunity to follow me on mislynching DrCJG then push for brainbomb.xorxes wrote: ↑Sat Dec 08, 2018 10:35 pmHow do you think town xorxes would have reacted? DrCJG voted for me for not showing interest in your hypo-proposal. Can't get scummier than that.bozotheclown wrote: ↑Sat Dec 08, 2018 5:54 pm
Here are some examples of things I would "not expect from town xorxes":
1. Your reaction to DrCJG after he voted for you.
You could have considered that he was wrong instead of scum.
What would you have expected town xorxes to do?2. Your following brainbomb onto RagingIke D1.
Stay on DrCJG's vanity wagon?
Vote for worcej with DrCJG?
Vote for damo?
Something else?
Vote for someone you suspected was scum, other than follow brainbomb claiming you were trying to bargain for his vote. I think RagingIke made that point at the time.
OK, fair enough. You scumread him for that and I didn't, at least not strongly enough to make a point about it. I thought it was consistent with Jamiet's behavior that day which seemed like town Jamiet to me. Obviously you were right and I was wrong. I think Jamiet started moving down my list sometime around that point, but I don't remember exactly when.3. Your town read of Jamie after D1.
Why do you think that's more likely from scum xorxes than from town xorxes?4. Your END vote on Jamie immediately after worcej's claim D2.
I think scum would prefer to shut down discussion and end the day early at that point.
Don't you think town xorxes would reevaluate his reads after knowing worcej and Jamiet's alignment?4. The unexplained change of your Nephthys read from one of your strongest town reads to one of your top two scum reads N2.
Sure, but you never explained what one had to do with the other.
You two were my top suspects, it may be that as I became more convinced about DrCJG I became less convinced about you, but I don't see why you would think that's scummy in any way.5. The apparent change in your read of me after I started pushing DrCJG D3.
You could have considered that he was wrong instead of scum.xorxes wrote: ↑Sat Dec 08, 2018 10:35 pmHow do you think town xorxes would have reacted? DrCJG voted for me for not showing interest in your hypo-proposal. Can't get scummier than that.bozotheclown wrote: ↑Sat Dec 08, 2018 5:54 pm
Here are some examples of things I would "not expect from town xorxes":
1. Your reaction to DrCJG after he voted for you.
Vote for someone you suspected was scum, other than follow brainbomb claiming you were trying to bargain for his vote. I think RagingIke made that point at the time.What would you have expected town xorxes to do?2. Your following brainbomb onto RagingIke D1.
Stay on DrCJG's vanity wagon?
Vote for worcej with DrCJG?
Vote for damo?
Something else?
I think scum would prefer to shut down discussion and end the day early at that point.OK, fair enough. You scumread him for that and I didn't, at least not strongly enough to make a point about it. I thought it was consistent with Jamiet's behavior that day which seemed like town Jamiet to me. Obviously you were right and I was wrong. I think Jamiet started moving down my list sometime around that point, but I don't remember exactly when.3. Your town read of Jamie after D1.
Why do you think that's more likely from scum xorxes than from town xorxes?4. Your END vote on Jamie immediately after worcej's claim D2.
Sure, but you never explained what one had to do with the other.Don't you think town xorxes would reevaluate his reads after knowing worcej and Jamiet's alignment?4. The unexplained change of your Nephthys read from one of your strongest town reads to one of your top two scum reads N2.
[/quote]You two were my top suspects, it may be that as I became more convinced about DrCJG I became less convinced about you, but I don't see why you would think that's scummy in any way.5. The apparent change in your read of me after I started pushing DrCJG D3.
The simple explanation is that Jamie NKed and RBed RagingIke in case RagingIke was the doctor protecting himself or the vig. The fact that you were RagingIke's top scum read would explain why he was the NK, and why you might be concerned about him being the vig.xorxes wrote: ↑Sat Dec 08, 2018 10:50 pmthdfrance
This one was short. Zero content from D1, just the terrorist thing with Jamiet, then mostly mechanics talk, and a vote for damo that everyone thought was horribly scummy. Then he disappears during N1.
One question that has been bothering me is why did they send their Roleblocker to do the kill when there could be a Tracker following him. If thdfrance was not around and for some reason Nephthys wasn't there either, that may sort of explain why Jamiet had to do it.
Is that a trick question? :)bozotheclown wrote: ↑Sun Dec 09, 2018 12:57 amIs sarcasm scum indicative for you?xorxes wrote: ↑Sat Dec 08, 2018 9:52 pmIt's good to know you will consider changing your mind if I get NKed, we were all wondering about that.bozotheclown wrote: ↑Sat Dec 08, 2018 6:00 pmI was hoping we could get a consensus on xorxes today. Unless xorxes get NKed, I do not see anything changing my mind D5.
its kinda odd for scum to nk a wagon with 2 ppl on it one of which is scum. it makes the scum on there a naked voter and delegated to a coin flip.bozotheclown wrote: ↑Sun Dec 09, 2018 1:23 amI hadn't thought about why RagingIke was the NK N1, but he would be the obvious choice for xorxes to want dead.