Mafia XL - A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum

[flash2015]

Flash, I know you've been reading. Any thoughts?

I am not sure. I don't see much yet suggesting Peter or Demon is scum so I am really tempted to vote for you. But, I am not keen on bucking tradition here. Since BB is not playing I understand that it is customary to vote for ghug on the first day...so that is what I will do while I think about this. ##vote ghug.

[flash2015]

Have we discussed the millers at all? Are the millers going to out themselves? I understand that on some mafia sites they have suggested it is good for millers to out themselves early. Anyone have any thoughts on this?

[Tom Bombadil]

Have we discussed the millers at all? Are the millers going to out themselves? I understand that on some mafia sites they have suggested it is good for millers to out themselves early. Anyone have any thoughts on this?

Millers don’t know they are millers. They get VT PMs

[flash2015]

OK, nvm. In this game the millers don't know they are millers.

[DrCJG]

@ Flash - Welcome. Glad to see i am not the only one to make the miller mistake

[yavuzovic]

@Yavu:

You said DrC and Worc were scummy? What is your reasoning on them now?

You were scumreading xorx for voting rapidly, which you even stated was a towny thing. Is this still the case?

Is your entire reason for voting me because I voted you?

DrCJG was a low poster, he isn't that scummy at the moment. Worcej, uhmmm, I must reread myself to answer this. Can't you quote my post telling those?
Xorxes is scummy and it's not for only what you said. He gives me scummy vibes from his posts. I can't give you a concrete reason but he is a scunread for me.

And no, not only for voting me. Read my vote post and the pist I referred there. Squigs gave a good reasoning there. I'm sheeping him because I like this case.

[RagingIke297]

The more I look at Dr.CJG, the more I'm getting scum vibes. If I've drawn scum 4 times in a row and never played town, I'm excited that I get to play the other side. He doesnt come off as excited, he almost comes off as cocky

No... I will definitely be fearkilled... this is my first game as town after 4 scum games... and I am just too much of a wildcard.

I don't see why scum would find him any more dangerous than Szpoti, its very possible Dr's town game is terrible, if he is town it's literally his first game. If I'm mafia I would hit someone with a solid town track record over a "wildcard" any day. Seems like an attempt to stay wagonless.

[ghug]

Can anyone look at thd and honestly claim he doesn't exude awkward scumminess?

I decidedly don't like the Ike, Peter, and damo votes right now. What's the case on RHK?

Flash, someone noted you were reading the thread well before you got subbed in. Does that mean you're caught up? Why haven't you offered any thoughts about things that have actually happened yet?

[DemonRHK]

@Yavu:

You said DrC and Worc were scummy? What is your reasoning on them now?

You were scumreading xorx for voting rapidly, which you even stated was a towny thing. Is this still the case?

Is your entire reason for voting me because I voted you?

DrCJG was a low poster, he isn't that scummy at the moment. Worcej, uhmmm, I must reread myself to answer this. Can't you quote my post telling those?
Xorxes is scummy and it's not for only what you said. He gives me scummy vibes from his posts. I can't give you a concrete reason but he is a scunread for me.

And no, not only for voting me. Read my vote post and the pist I referred there. Squigs gave a good reasoning there. I'm sheeping him because I like this case.

It’s hard for me to quote on mobile. Let me tell you what you said since you can’t seem to remember: Your worc scum read was a tack on afterpost you your reads list. The fact you can’t fucking remember it is telling.

Your vote on me is OMGUS and an admitted sheep. Your only other real vote was for Jamie on meta mostly. Do you now scumread flash or was that suddenly disappeared as well?

So all of your cases are gut feelings that aren’t explained, OMGUS, and nearly out-of-game meta.

Feels like 39 all over again. ##Vote Yavu

[Vecna]

##vote thd

time to try something creative and see what ghug is sniffing

[Tom Bombadil]

Ok.

##vote thdfrance.

@thdfrance:

What made you townread me at the beginning of the game? You said you were townrewding me but that read was cooling. Can you explain that further?

[DrCJG]

The more I look at Dr.CJG, the more I'm getting scum vibes. If I've drawn scum 4 times in a row and never played town, I'm excited that I get to play the other side. He doesnt come off as excited, he almost comes off as cocky

No... I will definitely be fearkilled... this is my first game as town after 4 scum games... and I am just too much of a wildcard.

I don't see why scum would find him any more dangerous than Szpoti, its very possible Dr's town game is terrible, if he is town it's literally his first game. If I'm mafia I would hit someone with a solid town track record over a "wildcard" any day. Seems like an attempt to stay wagonless.

@ Ike rather than throwing a little shade my way perhaps you should put a vote on who you think is scummy...

best I can tell you just followed Tom on to Peter for kicks... do you still think Peter is scum? ...

If so, why? If not, then follow your own call for consolidation...

4 hours until end of day, let's start consolidating people

[RagingIke297]

##vote thd until he answers my questions

[RagingIke297]

Dang it Tom, I'm going to find somewhere else to put my vote now, can't sheep Tom forever

[Durga]

I feel like this is right

##vote damo

[DrCJG]

I don't understand the move to thdfrance... It feels like the typical shift onto a newer player at the end of D1 for little to no reason... his posts seem loose and to have some level of original thought...

@ Ike - Do you have a reason to vote ThdFrance other then him having not answered your question about why he is voting you?

@ Thdfrance - How many games have you played?

[Tom Bombadil]

Dang it Tom, I'm going to find somewhere else to put my vote now, can't sheep Tom forever

Didn’t you just say DrCJG was scummy? And then you vote thd...

Also, I love the wording of “until he answers my questions”. When I see that my first thought is: Man he really wants to point out to everyone that he is asking questions...

[damo666]

I feel like this is right

##vote damo

If you are scum you know it is right (from a scum POV).

If you are town I can tell you your feel isn't right.

[RagingIke297]

Dang it Tom, I'm going to find somewhere else to put my vote now, can't sheep Tom forever

Didn’t you just say DrCJG was scummy? And then you vote thd...

Also, I love the wording of “until he answers my questions”. When I see that my first thought is: Man he really wants to point out to everyone that he is asking questions...

I didnt want to go against what I said about consolidation and start a new wagon. I don't particularly care if people notice I'm asking questions, I'm more interested in the answers

[DrCJG]

I didnt want to go against what I said about consolidation and start a new wagon. I don't particularly care if people notice I'm asking questions, I'm more interested in the answers

Ugh, Ike you better be scum because I am getting tunnel vision for you... every post you make just sounds scummier....

Since you are only concerned with the answers... care to give me yours?

@ Ike - Do you have a reason to vote ThdFrance other then him having not answered your question about why he is voting you?

Furthermore, if you don't care if people notice if your asking questions... why do you care if people notice you're sheeping Tom... all that matters is finding scum, right?