https://webdiplomacy.net/contrib/phpBB3/
https://webdiplomacy.net/contrib/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?f=4&t=1784
I was pretty convinced emc town and considered you more likely scum. Fwiw I now think both you and emc are town.bozotheclown wrote: ↑Fri Jul 19, 2019 3:44 pmWhat were you trying to accomplish with this if you are town?
its fun to try? not really easy to pull off, but definetely part of the enjoyment of being town and wanting to get it rightrdrivera2005 wrote: ↑Fri Jul 19, 2019 3:49 pmWhy people insist in trying to figure out the whole scumteam? Does this ever work?
I used to just yell at my top scumread until I could provoke an emotional resonse from them. which usually just turned into them calling me an idiot.rdrivera2005 wrote: ↑Fri Jul 19, 2019 3:51 pmYes and it's way better to play with you now. But you also had some great moments in the past when you didn't have a meltdown.
It's fun trying to figure out what scumteams work from a given scumpool and it's worth sharing. You're unlikely to nab the whole team but if you get commonality between attempts it's a good guide I think. For instance we have bo and Flash appearing quite a lot.rdrivera2005 wrote: ↑Fri Jul 19, 2019 3:49 pmWhy people insist in trying to figure out the whole scumteam? Does this ever work?
Much better just to try not to catch the scum, right?rdrivera2005 wrote: ↑Fri Jul 19, 2019 3:49 pmWhy people insist in trying to figure out the whole scumteam? Does this ever work?
I'm OK until Tues 23rd but for 6 days thereafter I will be intermittent at best (if I'm still surviving). I will of course comply with minimum requirements but may struggle to keep up.
I've got to give big Town points to anyone who discredits a proven towns reasoning to Town read you.
Darg begins game using gimmick of 1 word. and parks on percy. says percy is hedging.dargorygel
Day-1 47:58
page 1 / orig Hi!
dargorygel
Day-1 47:55
page 1 / orig Litterer!
dargorygel
Day-1 47:54
page 1 / orig ##VOTE PERCY WILLIAMS
dargorygel
Day-1 47:53
page 1 / orig Grumpkins?
dargorygel
Day-1 47:46
page 1 / orig Sustainability!
dargorygel
Day-1 24:19
page 28 / orig I'll be back tomorrow with time...
First, I was trying to be funny, and no one noticed. I was posting with one word. I suppose it says something about what folk expect from me.
It was kind of fun. Mostly it was just reactive posts. I DID have a couple of conversations (accusing Percy Williams of hedging, for instance) that were fun with single words. It actually made me think more about articulation than I am used to...
But in the end it is too hard and not really helpful.
A couple of obvious things to comment on:
Mass claim... while I do think that such a claim MIGHT POSSIBLY help us... mostly the concept has too many faulty underlying beliefs. It assumes a randomness of role that I don't think the GM's would do. It assumes that we will have LOTS of scum making false claims, when there is no reason for them to do so. I think bozo also is assuming (he lists this as a 'pro') that multiple fakeclaiming by lynchable scum is common. I think it happens maybe once or twice per game. So we MIGHT draw out a couple of scum... but mostly, we just give scum a map.
But I am not happy with how hard bozo is pushing for this. He seems to have some hope that he has a chance to succeed. I think bozo is smarter than that. So why does he not back off? Or did I miss a retraction?
Also, regarding D1 voting. I always raise an eyebrow at STRONG statements on D1. People who pretend to KNOW an alignment. Obv, only scum knows alignment.
Lynching lurkers? D1 is almost random voting, or at most, mostly gut feelings. Lurkers are no more or less likely to be scum. Lately, it seems, though that at least one or two scummies hide early in the game. So maybe lynching lurkers increases our odds.
I'll probably be able to read off and on... but won't have time to post much till tomorrow morning.
This seems like dargo had 2 reasons by now to unvote percy but didnt.Page 41
dargorygel
Day-1 06:46
page 41 / orig Maybe this is obv, but it seems that bozo's relentless pursuit of a massclaim makes the most sense if he is the role-thief. One role already responded and claimed mason. And of course, if he DOES convince enough people, he finds a bunch of roles.
now he says percy vote is a joke.
dargorygel
Day-1 06:39
page 42 / orig My Percy vote at first was clearly a joke vote. Did no one else notice that he was blamed in the flavor for the end of civilization?
I get the policy votes. MF this morning seems reasonable, though.
I do think we need a non-policy option.
Presently, I am clearly not choosing the wine in front of me...
And Percy has seemed more and more questionable to me. In addition to what otehrs have brought up, he seems to be PR fishing... emphasizing clarification of those who have soft-claimed.
So I'll leave it there, for now.
I would also vote for Itshusoko, bozo, or foxy today
bo_sox48
Day-1 17:27
page 37 / orig I was going to spend some time reading up on the latest events in the thread, but then Jamie took up my time in other ways. I need to cast a vote and the only moderate scumread I have so far is on darg, so ##VOTE darg. If I have time to be here later tonight that might change.
At this point already darg looks like a vulnerable towny that scum know they can feast on.Chaqa
Day-1 23:33
page 29 / orig
↑dargorygel: "I'll be back tomorrow with time...
First, I was trying to be funny, and no one noticed. I was posting with one word. I..."
Before I dive into this post, thanks bo for articulating what I’ve been feeling in a way more clear and concise way than I ever could. Appreciate that. I have a lot of trouble following all these back and forth quoted conversations. I miss the old big monolithic “case” posts people used to make.
But on this post - dargo isn’t someone I’ve played with too much (or have forgotten if I gave), but this entire post seems hedgey and anchoring. “Sorry I was posting so poorly, but weren’t my one-word answers so articulate! I’ll be back and better later, I promise!”
Blegh. ##Vote dargo
Make that 3 scummy ppl who pushed dargorygel.
Vaporwave
Day-1 07:03
page 41 / orig Because I might not come back, I'm not leaving my vote on MF
Moscow won't change even if we policy lynch him for his playstyle + I'm not a player that votes for past offenses so my reason feels non-game related
##VOTE dargorygel
it feels SO much better now
In M24, you and dargorygel both made it through the entire game (7 days). In M28, you both were alive for 5 days. You were both in M33, but dargorygel replaced you D5. In M36 you were both on the scum team, although you were replaced D2.Chaqa wrote: ↑Wed Jul 17, 2019 7:27 pmBefore I dive into this post, thanks bo for articulating what I’ve been feeling in a way more clear and concise way than I ever could. Appreciate that. I have a lot of trouble following all these back and forth quoted conversations. I miss the old big monolithic “case” posts people used to make.dargorygel wrote: ↑Wed Jul 17, 2019 6:41 pmI'll be back tomorrow with time...
First, I was trying to be funny, and no one noticed. I was posting with one word. I suppose it says something about what folk expect from me.
It was kind of fun. Mostly it was just reactive posts. I DID have a couple of conversations (accusing Percy Williams of hedging, for instance) that were fun with single words. It actually made me think more about articulation than I am used to...
But in the end it is too hard and not really helpful.
A couple of obvious things to comment on:
Mass claim... while I do think that such a claim MIGHT POSSIBLY help us... mostly the concept has too many faulty underlying beliefs. It assumes a randomness of role that I don't think the GM's would do. It assumes that we will have LOTS of scum making false claims, when there is no reason for them to do so. I think bozo also is assuming (he lists this as a 'pro') that multiple fakeclaiming by lynchable scum is common. I think it happens maybe once or twice per game. So we MIGHT draw out a couple of scum... but mostly, we just give scum a map.
But I am not happy with how hard bozo is pushing for this. He seems to have some hope that he has a chance to succeed. I think bozo is smarter than that. So why does he not back off? Or did I miss a retraction?
Also, regarding D1 voting. I always raise an eyebrow at STRONG statements on D1. People who pretend to KNOW an alignment. Obv, only scum knows alignment.
Lynching lurkers? D1 is almost random voting, or at most, mostly gut feelings. Lurkers are no more or less likely to be scum. Lately, it seems, though that at least one or two scummies hide early in the game. So maybe lynching lurkers increases our odds.
I'll probably be able to read off and on... but won't have time to post much till tomorrow morning.
But on this post - dargo isn’t someone I’ve played with too much (or have forgotten if I gave), but this entire post seems hedgey and anchoring. “Sorry I was posting so poorly, but weren’t my one-word answers so articulate! I’ll be back and better later, I promise!”
Blegh. ##Vote dargo
any idea what hes talking about?bo_sox48
Day-1 17:27
page 37 / orig I was going to spend some time reading up on the latest events in the thread, but then Jamie took up my time in other ways. I need to cast a vote and the only moderate scumread I have so far is on darg, so ##VOTE darg. If I have time to be here later tonight that might change
I Highly doubt I'm N1 NK. Since I can't prove I'm Town until At least Day 5, the mafia have plenty of time to orchestrate my mislynch. People are going to start suspecting me again as soon as I live through a couple nights, despite it not making that much sense to NK me, they might let me live past turn 5 and push for my mislynch. Although I'd have no reason not to claim my scan, and once I flip people will know it's true, but I still think the mafia will push a mislynch rather than NK me.
Why not just vote for me then? What did changing your vote accomplish?damo666 wrote: ↑Fri Jul 19, 2019 3:49 pmI was pretty convinced emc town and considered you more likely scum. Fwiw I now think both you and emc are town.bozotheclown wrote: ↑Fri Jul 19, 2019 3:44 pmWhat were you trying to accomplish with this if you are town?
brainbomb wrote: ↑Fri Jul 19, 2019 12:06 pmby the way, since when is webdip mafia a lesson in redisciplining players how theyre supposed to play.
the whole wagon on emc was about behavioral correction because he always waits til ten minutes left in a phase to vote.
Im trying to understand when we replaced scumhunting with scolding lynches.
did you losers all go get girls pregnant and decide you needed some fatherhood practice
When is the first night you can scan?Percy Williams wrote: ↑Fri Jul 19, 2019 4:21 pmI Highly doubt I'm N1 NK. Since I can't prove I'm Town until At least Day 5, the mafia have plenty of time to orchestrate my mislynch. People are going to start suspecting me again as soon as I live through a couple nights, despite it not making that much sense to NK me, they might let me live past turn 5 and push for my mislynch. Although I'd have no reason not to claim my scan, and once I flip people will know it's true, but I still think the mafia will push a mislynch rather than NK me.
