webdiplomacy.net

RIP worcej and bozo, you all shall be missed

Sorry guys, was supposed to be here @EOD, but overslept sadly

brainbomb wrote: ↑

Wed Sep 18, 2019 10:23 pm

the only bad thing is that we dont know if thanos used that pre claim
which means thanos might be ND after all

lol

True.

Thanos would probably want to be on the lynching wagon in case there's a stone to be had though. That makes our best candidates for Thanos:

Nephthys
rdrivera2005
BunnyGo
Kitsune
KalelChase
brainbomb
EspressoPatronum

There's an argument to be made that Thanos would not be on the wagon though, so I guess that's not saying a lot.

Note 4: Players may at give stones to other players by contacting a GM, they must not knowingly go against their Win Con, all orders submitted will be carried out at the end of the phase, once ALL other actions have taken place.

So bozo could NOT have had the stone, and the stone cannot be given away in case of danger of being lynched. That means Thanos would indeed want to be on the lynch wagon as often as possible.

was the guy online? That Serial Killer

because it was specifically used for bozo's wagon

Vaporwave wrote: ↑

Wed Sep 18, 2019 10:44 pm

was the guy online? That Serial Killer

because it was specifically used for bozo's wagon

Unless it was used on someone that moved to bozo at the last minute.

that power stone can be used as often as possible, doesn't seem to have a cool off time

so this serial killer can't be NK and it's hard to get him killed because he can make his counterwagon get lynched instead

what an invincible guy

vig keep it shush...and think thrice or even more than that before shooting

I wanna see a one of a kind vig shot

get that bastard of a SK and have us make faces

bozo became lead wagon with 4 votes when worcej was shot.

Kalel was 5th vote with 22 minutes to go
brain was 6th vote with 21 minutes to go
EP was 7th vote with 3 minutes to go

Those three are the top Thanos suspects right now, I would say.

@bb, please tell me you are not Thanos?

@Kalel

Agreed, if that was sincerely meant then it could still be very useful information.

Snipping the top 5 on the list to look at, we have:

Espresso 8
Kalel 8
emc 7
bozo 6
Chaqa 4

Let's... politely ignore bozo's name out of respect and look at the rest using Food's heuristic.

Espresso - I don't necessarily trust his reads (because I can't, and because some of them are based on meta I'm not privy to) but he's actually growing on me with a positive and investigative style. I'm pushing Townlean here. He was in on the mistaken lynch of Bozo, as was I.

Kalel - Going back through his post list for Day 1, I'm starting to realise how little there was actually there. I still can't find anything bad there, but with the second lowest posting stats among players (yes, even yuuki came back with a vengeance) and precious little meat or investigation in his posts when they did come I'm pushing scumlean here. Newbie solidarity or no. He was in on the mistaken lynch of Bozo, as was I.

Emc - A long absence near the start which I'm fully aware from out-of-game reasons was genuine (*glare*) doesn't look great, but he came back with a vengeance to be a roughly middle poster. One good post around page 44, and then some solid reasoning vs Maniac and on the last minute voting shift. I'm pushing null here for our tiny overlord. Although if he starts snipping my hair I'm going to step on him. He voted Maniac, along with Xorxes.

Chaqa - Down in the low-posters again (18 according to the bot, which yes I'm learning to use). Low participation too, it feels like he's going along with the flow rather than offering up any new information or arguments. He claims that's his meta and most of you seem to accept that, but based on what I can see myself I'm thinking scumlean here until we see more of the active Detective Chaqa on the case. He voted ND, along with six others. Thanos did not prefer this lynch.

Thoughts: Why is humour and helpfulness a sign of being scummy? That seems like it would be helpful for a town pulling together to figure who is right and who is dead?

xorxes wrote: ↑

Wed Sep 18, 2019 10:33 pm

brainbomb wrote: ↑

Wed Sep 18, 2019 10:23 pm

the only bad thing is that we dont know if thanos used that pre claim
which means thanos might be ND after all

lol

True.

Thanos would probably want to be on the lynching wagon in case there's a stone to be had though. That makes our best candidates for Thanos:

Nephthys
rdrivera2005
BunnyGo
Kitsune
KalelChase
brainbomb
EspressoPatronum

There's an argument to be made that Thanos would not be on the wagon though, so I guess that's not saying a lot.

That's an interesting question. Would SK risk being discovered (or at last restricting a lot the possibilites) to get a stone or just use his power to generate confusion and hide deeper.

Anyway, good move from Bozo and I was wrong about him again

Have to reconsider some things.

Vaporwave wrote: ↑

Wed Sep 18, 2019 10:48 pm

that power stone can be used as often as possible, doesn't seem to have a cool off time

so this serial killer can't be NK and it's hard to get him killed because he can make his counterwagon get lynched instead

what an invincible guy

Not really, we just need to keep the leading wagon with two vote distance (for now) as he can't have more then one Stone at this point.

actually xorxes, it really bothered me how bomb kept mentioning that SK character, always talking about him and accusing people of roleplaying him

don't think anyone else has been so concerned with SK as bb,

he was supposedly looking for SK in others, maybe that was just him projecting

I think id probably play the game of my life as thanos and be alot crazier than I am

you could certainly argue im more measured than usual. less combative.

but really nothing to be upset about.

have a nice night phase xorxes.

what a shitshow

Vaporwave wrote: ↑

Wed Sep 18, 2019 10:58 pm

actually xorxes, it really bothered me how bomb kept mentioning that SK character, always talking about him and accusing people of roleplaying him

don't think anyone else has been so concerned with SK as bb,

he was supposedly looking for SK in others, maybe that was just him projecting

scum brainbomb trying to eliminate a threat maybe?

rdrivera2005 wrote: ↑

Wed Sep 18, 2019 10:58 pm

Vaporwave wrote: ↑

Wed Sep 18, 2019 10:48 pm

that power stone can be used as often as possible, doesn't seem to have a cool off time

so this serial killer can't be NK and it's hard to get him killed because he can make his counterwagon get lynched instead

what an invincible guy

Not really, we just need to keep the leading wagon with two vote distance (for now) as he can't have more then one Stone at this point.

He will be getting a 2nd stone soon though, and we will lose gamora.

yuuki wrote: ↑

Wed Sep 18, 2019 11:04 pm

Vaporwave wrote: ↑

Wed Sep 18, 2019 10:58 pm

actually xorxes, it really bothered me how bomb kept mentioning that SK character, always talking about him and accusing people of roleplaying him

don't think anyone else has been so concerned with SK as bb,

he was supposedly looking for SK in others, maybe that was just him projecting

scum brainbomb trying to eliminate a threat maybe?

I doubt very much that brainbomb is scum. Jury still out on the Thanos question.